Yesterday I had a new client walk in as I was on my way out the door. Psyched that I was finally going to make it to my spinning class at least one day this week, I (only briefly) thought of telling the receptionist to inform the gentleman that I had already absconded. Guilt stayed my hand on the keys in the ignition. And when I saw what this new client had in his purple plastic kitty carrier I was relieved to see I’d made the right decision.
The kitty-cat, a two-year-old tabby specimen, was recumbent, feverish, and painful. This was the third hospital he’d been to that afternoon. Lacking a regular vet (let’s leave that issue aside for the moment), he’d gone to the first large hospital he could find.
The first hospital quickly informed him of his cat’s condition. Kitty had a urinary obstruction. His bladder was huge and painful and, as a result, deadly toxins were building in his bloodstream that would certainly kill him if the bladder was not relieved. When an estimate for well over a thousand dollars was presented, the client (a young student from a family of recent immigrants with few resources) felt he had no choice but to take his pet to a less expensive hospital. They sent him to the animal ER down the street.
The animal ER, just opening its doors for the evening, echoed the estimate and referred him to me. The ER staff felt that if any regular vet could see him his bill would be manageable compared to an ER`s up-charge for convenience and emergency hours. And I was close by.
By the time I saw Kitty, the owner was frazzled, scared for his cat, and confused by the plethora of options that confronted him. Kitty, needless to say, was well on his way to that bright light at the end of the tunnel.
Before bothering with an estimate I unblocked the poor thing. He was so weak no anesthetic was required, just a sedating pain reliever. Passing a catheter through his tiny penis into the urethra and then the bladder, this action was quickly accomplished.
Now that the situation was somewhat under control I was able to talk to the poor shell-shocked client. I explained the condition and offered a wide variety of options. No surprise here: he chose the least expensive approach. For fewer than four hundred dollars I can’t practice medicine the way I’d like to but I can still save a blocked cat’s life.
Not everyone has the means to spend big bucks on a housecat when something goes terribly wrong. And perhaps that means they shouldn’t have one. But it’s not my job to judge. In this case my job was to unblock a blocked cat to save its life and come up with a workable financial solution for a struggling family—afterwards.
The sad truth of this story is that a pet owner that does not understand even the simple system of getting care for a pet in the US will fall through its cracks more easily. This cat might have died in another hour or two. What if the client had given up? He certainly had cause to be frustrated with the process.
Because this client expressed his money problems with the reception staff, as I was later informed, no vet ever examined the cat or talked to him directly. Receptionists and technicians at both preceding hospitals were charged with assessing his cat’s condition. Vets wrote up estimates without even looking at Kitty or talking to his owner.
Ultimately, hospital policy was as responsible for prolonging Kitty’s near-death experience as his owner’s failure to establish a relationship with a vet before the emergency. Which one is more forgivable?
Truth is, most vets don’t want to deal with new clients in emergency situations—especially clients who have expressed an inability to pay for services. This is a fact of doing business in any setting—no money is no good for business. While medicine should be different, that doesn’t change the common outcome: poor people don’t get proper healthcare for themselves, much less for their pets.
To a certain extent, all vets are guilty of making snap determinations that can unwittingly lead to a pet`s death. For example: the client has no money, I gotta get to the gym, whatever...
Working in an ER for many years hardened me to this reality: If you can’t pay we can’t treat. And working in a traditional hours setting has softened me to another: my lifestyle matters so that getting home to my child or to the gym is important, too.
Now that I have more control over how I practice (because I work in a hospital that gives me license to undertake less-than-standard-of-care protocols when needed) I enjoy my work more. But I still worry about all those pets who go without when we fall asleep—whether on the job or at night, snug in our beds.
Add Comment10 Comments
Great blog! I just discovered it through Dr. Susan's space. I'm busy catching up on past stories but look forward to new posts as well.
Shannon
Shannon August 24th, 2006 04:45:00 PM
Good for you! I work for a vet that would probably have left rather than look at the cat. I'm glad to know that there are people like you out there. I'm enjoying reading your blog.
Kelly August 24th, 2006 09:22:00 PM
Shannon and Kelly: Thanks for the boost! If there`s anything in particular you want to read about just let me know. email me at drkhuly@dolittler.com. Have fun!
Dr. Patty Khuly August 25th, 2006 06:27:00 AM
I think more people need to be made aware of programs like Care Credit, (although not everyone would qualify for approval). There are a number of emergency care assistance programs around the country (nonprofit groups who will pay towards a vet bill), but they require the bill to be paid first, and then they rule on whether to contribute afterwards. That's not going to help a lot in a real life or death emergency, or where the owner just doesn't have any money to even make a deposit on payment.
One thing I'd support would be free euthanasia services, especially at emergency clinics. I've read of situations where people with no money took injured pets (say, hit by car) to an emergency clinic, only to be turned away completely. That seems unfair to the pet if it's in pain -- I'd like the owners to have the option of having it humanely euthanized, at least. I'd even be willing to chip in $1 or $5 or whatever on my own regular vet bills to have it go into an emergency fund for those sorts of cases.
There used to be another vet blog online, but the owner took it down earlier this year. It's too bad, because she had a great entry with a few dozen replies about problems people had encountered at emergency clinics. If people can discuss the problems they've had in the past, maybe it would lead to finding some small solutions.
Leigh-Ann August 25th, 2006 03:00:00 PM
Don`t get me started on the pet ER topic--my list of complaints (and the stories to support them) would never end. Ultimately, it`s still a business. But there has to be some way of doing it right. In my experience, everything rests on the integrity and ability of the vet that is on duty. Sometimes it`s amazing care you get. Sometimes you`d have been better off staying home. Those odds are neither measurable of great. Care Credit is good, I`ll warrant, but anyone without a major credit card is likely not going to be approved. There`s the rub. I`ve seen it happen too often, especially in Miami where our recent immigrant population is so high. But as to euthanasia--I give it away in those situations. It costs me so little ($35 for a small dog?) and it lets me sleep a night. We need more foundations that specifically address these unworkable cases. Thanks, Leigh-Ann.
-Patty
Dr. Patty Khuly August 26th, 2006 01:27:00 PM
Thank you Dr. Patty for treating this kitty. We live in an area that is a little short on vet care, and have to do the best we can sometimes. My area is not a rich economic area by any means either, but a lot of people have pets and do the best they can. I know a lot of people say if you can't afford the best care, then don't have pets, but a lot of people say the same about kids. Thank you for realizing this pet owner, as well as the cat needed your help and compassion. I am sure he loved his pet very much. He could have just let it suffer or abandoned it somewhere when he heard what it would cost. You are to be commended.
Verna Sherrer September 11th, 2006 10:53:00 PM
Thank you Dr. K for treating this patient. Not only did you provide relief for the suffering kitty. You validated your human client's love & concern for his cat.
barb r. June 19th, 2007 04:27:00 PM
Your comments are offensive. I am a former vet tech and I would never work for someone like you, or recommend anyone to you.
You're right - it's not your job to judge anyone. Doctor-Ego is what you have.
Gia September 14th, 2007 08:08:00 PM
Gia: Ummmm....sure, I 've been accused of that and I'll own it. But what would you have done differently? I like to stimulate discussion on this blog. If you have a specific point to make, go for it--but do it nicely...please? We all have feelings.
Dr. Patty Khuly September 16th, 2007 05:07:00 PM
Blu ray Ripper
gdsf October 5th, 2009 10:00:49 PM
Add Commment