Ever get up in the middle of the night to the distinctive sound of Fido retching uncontrollably in a corner? Or to piles of bloody stool dappled across the bedroom floor? How about the invariably alarming midnight seizure? You’re not alone. It happens to us all at some point.
Next thing you know you’re driving, bleary-eyed and panicky, into the streets with sick pet in tow in search of your friendly neighborhood emergency hospital—which in too many cases is neither friendly nor remotely in your neighborhood.
If you’re lucky, perhaps your own vet keeps a beeper or an on site emergency service. With the advent of large-scale emergency hospitals and specialty clinics, however, this homier scenario has become progressively less likely. When you call your vet in 2006, chances are you’ll be redirected to the nearest 24-hour facility.
You’ll stumble in through its doors, carrying a meowling, bleeding Fluffy, only to be told by the surly woman working hard to keep her three jobs that the doctor is in surgery so you’ll have to wait 30 minutes. (I drove like a maniac for this? Who does surgery at three AM anyway?) If you’d only arrived earlier, you muse…but then you might have been the fourth in line for the doctor’s attention.
After twenty minutes you’re starting to think your time would have been better spent at the Dunkin Donuts purchasing a box of bribes. Finally…the doctor will see you now. Seemingly competent and surprisingly alert, the vet expertly sutures up Fluffy`s wound and returns her to you in exchange for six hundred dollars of your cash. You’re shocked, but then…who else was going to fix Fluffy at 4 AM?
A few hours later, at approximately 8 AM, you spy blood on your tile. A trail leads directly to Fluffy`s favorite sleeping spot where you notice her violently pulling at her stitches with her teeth. Now it’s time to load up again and drive to your regular vet who will doubtless feel slightly responsible for your having spent $600 on something he would have done for $150 had you waited four more hours.
Now take care—I’m not advocating you ever delay seeking medical attention in order to see your own vet, just know that, on average, you will pay 100 to 200% more at most emergency hospitals. Why else would anyone work those hours if not to be paid a premium for his or her services?
What inevitably happens at these facilities, however, is that explanation and option presentation takes a backseat to expediency and defensive medicine (especially at 3AM or on any given Sunday). This means that 1- the vet will typically offer only exactly what she thinks is best for your pet and 2-the best medicine is also the medicine that searches tirelessly for problems so as to ward of any lawyers that may ask: And why, Dr. X, did you not take an X-ray of Fluffy`s lacerated paw? Consequently, panels of bloodwork, X-rays, and plenty of medications are always administered (this is clearly a worthy subject for another post).
Pet owners are almost always provided an estimate before any service is rendered (beyond the basic exam). And most will gasp. But they won’t always grasp the inherent element of choice in declining any of the products or procedures on the itemized list. They just want Fluffy fixed. If they have the money it will usually get spent.
For the record, should the estimate appear unusually high, there are four possibilities: 1-your pet is very sick and needs lots of care, 2-you have no earthly idea what things are supposed to cost, 3-the hospital is running up the bill (because the vet wants to or because the vet is under pressure to do so) or 4-because they’re being expedient and/or defensive (see above).
Nonetheless, every client has the right to ask to speak to the vet about the costs and to attempt to ascertain whether certain tests and procedures are absolutely necessary. That may be impossible without extensive knowledge, and I wouldn’t expect most clients to be that savvy, but it helps to let the staff and the vet know that while you respect them, and you still want everything possible done for your pet, money is indeed an issue. My advice? Kill `em with sugar but stay firm and you’re doing the best you can for your charge in these trying situations. I know it’s hard.
The stressful part of all this for me, the general practitioner, is that I know Fluffy. I know that she needed X when she received Y. I know that she didn’t need those two extra tests. Furthermore, I have a vested interest in being judicious about spending your money.
It irks me, too, to see you pay so much—not just because were it not after hours that income would have been mine, and not just because now you have nothing left over to spend on resuturing her (when they should have sent you home with an e-collar), but mostly because I know you and I feel frustrated on your behalf.
Moreover, whenever I send you elsewhere, that elsewhere is a reflection of me and the quality of my recommendations. It sucks when they f--- up or charge you four times more for what may turn out to be a lower quality of service. (Truthfully, I can say that—in my area—this happens about 25% of the time—maybe you`re luckier.)
But that’s the breaks guys. Unless I suit up and head out with my bagged dinner at 7 PM, I’m in not a great position to complain. I do anyway, but only when the damage is egregious. That’s why I still give out my cell phone number. I won’t usually get out of bed, but I will call to make sure Fluffy isn’t X-rayed for her superficial laceration.
Add Comment8 Comments
I recently had such an experience. While bathing my mom's dogs, I noticed that one, a 6-year-old spayed lab, was straining to urinate and dripping blood. I work for a vet and have a fair amount of knowledge - I figured she had a nasty bladder infection or stones, and she needed attention quick. Unfortunately, it was about 7 pm on a Sunday and my regular vet was out of town. Off we went to the animal emergency center, where she ended up staying overnight. The total bill came to about $700 to diagnose a bladder stone (not including the consequential cystotomy). Certainly the blood work, urinalysis, and x-rays were necessary, but I could've done without the over-priced fecal floatation and heartworm test. While I don't regret the care she received - I had anxiously told them to do whatever they felt was necessary - I will definitely take the few minutes next time to differentiate between necessary stabilizing treatment and routine care that can be taken care of by my regular vet.
anna November 21st, 2006 04:11:00 PM
I've used an emergency vet twice. Once when petsitting, because the dog only wanted to mope- he did not want to go out and "go" so I called and asked the vet's opinion. Fortunately, I got that dog's regular vet, and she told me that at that age and circumstance, he probably would not have to go as often as I had planned on showing up. Sure enough, he "went" on my third visit in the 24 hour period. Did not have to take the dog in. No charge.
The other time was when I was living in an apartment sharing a balcony with a couple of young men. They got kittens. We had our 5 cats at that time. We all left the balcony doors open in good weather and the cats went back and forth. We were the third floor of the building. The men were playing cards and drinking with my spouse. I heard a commotion. Apparently one of the kittens had fallen off. Fortunately, she ran around the building and waited at the front door to be let in. But when she just sat in a corner "groggy", I was summoned. I drove and made the arrangements, being the sober one. The vet did a very thorough but quick check and announced she had cleft her palate in the fall but was otherwise okay. Did not take x-rays. Did give us pain medication. Made follow up appointment for a week or so later. She recovered quickly, without having a padded bill. I liked the vet very much. Apparently my vet's office and his office and a couple of others have a system for emergency rotation. I like it. I hope I never need it again.
Georg November 21st, 2006 07:51:00 PM
I had a wretched experience with an emergency vet clinic when my kitty fell ill. I took her twice in one week since her condition showed up one evening and then became drastically worse over the weekend - neither times when her regular vet was available. Both times, the emergency vet insisted x-rays were necessary to diagnose the condition (the second set b/c the first didn't show the right part of her spine). The sad truth is that a simple blood test would have diagnosed her illness properly the first time. The good news is that the vet who takes care of my kitties now is very good about explaining treatment options, both in terms of effectiveness and price. With her, I know that my kitties are really getting the care they need.
Posey November 21st, 2006 09:43:00 PM
In the last year I have to use our local emergency vet twice...once for each of my dogs. The first time my girl had an ""unspecified" blood disorder, lack of platelets for clotting blood and my regular vet sent me there so she could be monitored 24/7 over the weekend, to be sure she didn't suffer from internal bleeding before medication could take hold. Did it cost a bunch? You bet. Would I do it again? You bet. The second incident was when my boy began having uncontrollable bloody diahrrea and vomiting after normal vet hours, a couple of days after my girl came home. Back to the emergency vet...I was given an treatment plan, estimate and made the choice of "do this and this and let's see what we learn from that"...they didn't in any way make me feel obligated to have more tests than necessary. The x-rays showed no obstruction, the blood tests were negative for blood disorder, and the diagnosis was "stress"...brought on by the chaos and confusion of the days without his friend...he is a rescue dog and is afraid of all other dogs, but does just fine with my girl. I thought the emergency vets, and all the technicians were wonderful. I am very glad they are here and tell everyone I know with pets that there is a good place to turn after hours.
Mari Lynn November 21st, 2006 11:04:00 PM
The first time I met you was when my male dog attacked my female puppy 4 days after we adopted her. It was traumatic. I brought her to one of the supermarket petstore clinics where I had purchased a contract and the vet said she needed surgery (, drains, tests, the works. After keeping her for five hours they called to say that they couldn't operate because she had eaten and to come pick her up. My husband called your office, made an appointment first thing in the morning. You said that she didn't need surgery. We cancelled the contract with the clinic, paid them off (more than $150) and I'm grateful.
It's Thanksgiving, so I don't want to bitch...but, how dare they! It's been three years, the dogs get along very well, yet it still angers me.
Also, about the Elizabethan Collar...When Gracie did need surgery I chose the paper/plastic model, and flipped it. Gracie looked as though she was wearing a skirt around her neck. It covered the stiches, she was able to see out and didn't end up knocking into walls, etc.
Janet
Janet (Cody and Gracie's mom) November 22nd, 2006 07:47:00 PM
Our emergency vet is the LSU vet school. They do charge a lot but they were very helpful when my dog ate aleo vera. (Who knew dogs couldn't eat aloe vera). Well you probably knew but I didn't. Now I have checked the entire list of things dogs cannot ingest and am hoping you will write a blog on Christmas stuff. I am particularly interest in what is the safest live tree to buy that won't poison the dog. I hear the sap gets in the water and can be dagerous to dogs.
Emily November 23rd, 2006 08:53:00 PM
One of the many reasons that I *adore* our local vets is that they do run an after hours pager service - it's a 6 vet practice. They can't do a lot of intervention after hours, but they always call back, and on several occasions have saved us from making the 1 hour+ drive to the Emerg vet, and the consequently massive bill. That, and the fact that they are great people...and obviously in the right profession - like you!
Erika November 24th, 2006 12:54:00 PM
We took our chronically blocked cat George to our ER clinic, and not only were we treated rudely, we were told that we needed to pay $850 for them to x-ray, catheterize, urine collect and analyze, medicate and do bloodwork. Thank you, but no freakin way.
We paid $200 to have the cat catheterized, enough to get past the "emergency" part of the situation, and were waiting on our vet's doorstep the next morning for further treatment. The only other time we've ended up at this particular clinic was to purchase some kitten milk for a foster kitten on a holiday monday. We paid $17 for a $4 can of kitten milk. Grrrrr.
Now we go to a clinic in the next town that is open 24/7. Their emergency fee is double their regular exam fee (which is still quite reasonable) and all their other services are charged at regular prices. In fact, they are SO reasonable, we occasionally pay the emerg visit fee just to get them in on a Sunday afternoon when one of the fosters needs a vaccine visit and I can't get a ride during normal hours. Their regular fees are so low that a normal appointment in my city costs MORE than the emerg fees.
Plus, there is nothing more comforting than having your pets entire medical history available at 4am in an emergency.
Kim November 27th, 2006 04:23:00 PM
Add Commment