Vetcetera Visiting the city of my dreams…wistful veterinary musings on New York City

November 25th, 2006  

Add Comment6 Comments

I guess happiness is where you find it. I live in a rural area, and I am never comfortable in a city environment. My 2 labs have a couple acres of yard to play in, miles and miles of woods and creeks that we can explore together. They sleep in a comfy king-size bed with me (along with my 2 cats). I feel all are well cared-for and happy. They really don't need fancy sweaters, but they do have blaze-orange vests to wear outside in the yard in hunting season (just in case some hunter gets too close to my yard). All are vaccinated, fed quality food, and are loved and cared for as family members. All live indoors; the cats are never outside(except maybe on the deck for short periods with supervision in summer). Does that make me less a loving and caring pet parent than a city dweller because I don't have to adjust my lifestyle as much? I personally would not think that large energetic dogs would be as happy in a city apartment as in a country setting with lots of room to run and play. I also could make more money in a city, but could never be truly comfortable there. I guess we all make some sacrifices to live the life we feel best suits us and our pets.

Shellie November 25th, 2006 12:51:00 PM

Thats funny. I just rented an apartment fo $40 extra per month because it was downstairs rather than upstairs and I didn't want my older dog to have to climb the stairs every day. I also picked this location because it is close to the only dog park in the city. But yes Shelly I would much rather be in the country and I think my dogs would happlily trade their daily park visits for a couple of acres.

Emily November 25th, 2006 09:52:00 PM

I hope my previous comment didn't seem to imply that I disapprove of city living, or of having pets in a city apartment. We all live where we do for a variety of reasons, not the least of which is earning a living. I love what the city has to offer in the way of culture and activities, and I love to visit cities for those reasons. But I have always been a country girl, born and raised with lots of space, dogs, cats, horses, etc. So after a couple days in the city, exciting as it is to me, I begin to feel a little claustrophobic and get anxious to return to my "comfort zone". I agree with Dr. Patty that city living demands more in the way of adaptation to accommodate the four-legged family members, and I admire those who love their animals enough to make the sacrifices necessary to keep them happy and healthy. So, Emily, my hat's off to you for doing so; please don't think that I am in any way disapproving. Your dog is a lucky dog indeed, to have you as such a caring "mom".

Shellie November 26th, 2006 12:51:00 AM

I`d heartily agree that any self-respecting dog would much prefer the country to the city. My sister`s dogs just moved from 500 lush acres adjacent to a national park to the city. They are not so happy as they once were. It`s obvious. But when you see dedicated owners do everything possible to make up for what their pets can`t have it really warms your heart. I guess that`s what makes me happy when I see pets in the city.

Dr. Patty Khuly November 26th, 2006 10:05:00 AM

The animals I have seen most in cities aren't the pets, and that's what I tend to think of... the scrawny dogs dumpster diving, the alley cats hunting rats in the night. I don't like cities very much. I live in suburbia, and I can walk half a mile and see undeveloped woods. I've had a deer in my fenced yard twice.

Georg November 26th, 2006 10:46:00 AM

Shelly just to clear things up. I didn't find you comment the least bit offensive so don't worry! I'm a country girl myself. I currently live in the city because I am in law school. It is my final year and I can't wait to buy a house in the country! I miss it so much that we sometimes go on day hikes my dogs love it.

Emily November 26th, 2006 07:34:00 PM

Add Commment

Your Name:

CAPTCHA Verification