Vet P.O.V. CC the Cat turns 5! Cat cloning is more than just about the menace or success of weird science

December 22nd, 2006  

Add Comment6 Comments

CC actually stands for "Carbon Copy."

Love your blog! Thanks for writing, and Happy Holidays!

Bettie December 22nd, 2006 10:45:00 AM

But cloning doesn't mean that the new animal will have the same personality, right? And with cats, it doesn't even mean that they would have the same coloring, right? I realize that's less an issue with purebreds, but most cats aren't purebreds.

I know that the idea of our pets dying is terribly painful; I cry over animal death reports more than I do human death reports (does that make me horrible?). But to me it feels really vain to try to recreate such a beloved creature. The fact that there are no other cats on earth like the ones I own and love is part of what makes them super special to me. Plus, there's the issue of bringing a cat into the world on purpose (through cloning or breeding) when there are so many homeless cats euthanized every year, or at the very least, living their lives in shelters. Lots of those homeless cats have super cool personalities, too. Maybe different than your cat's personality, but still super cool.

I always find it interesting that some people come into the cat shelter where I volunteer looking for a replica of their dearly departed feline, while others don't want anything to do with a cat that looks anything like the deceased. People grieve in such different ways.

Stacy December 22nd, 2006 11:18:00 AM

Stacy: I cry more over animals than over people too! Which is why I couldn't volunteer at an animal shelter, although I love volunteering (as a chaplain) in a human hospital.

Last night I visited with a patient who was seriously ill. She and her husband requested prayer, and when I asked if there was anything other than health issues that they wanted me to pray for, she hesitated and then asied shyly, "Do you think pets are important?

I said, "Of COURSE pets are important!"

She and her husband are worried about a pet finch who flew off two weeks ago. They told me all about the bird's antics, and when I told them that my husband and I keep a finch feeder up all year round (as many other people do, too), they told me what their bird looked like, so I can look for him. We prayed for his survival and health.

Later in the evening, I had a patient who was very worried about a dog left at home. That's really common; the hospital staff sometimes work with Animal Control staff to make sure that patients' pets will be okay while their people are in the hospital.

Susan December 22nd, 2006 11:48:00 AM

Absolutely no one can be my Colin who would sleep with me on the couch with his face pressed to mine, even if it was a clone. And no one will be my Rascal who I leash trained and would play fetch and sleep on my hair on my pillow (both cats, both unfortunately deceased). Even if I was offered their clone, they could not be the same cat. And without their passing, I would not have met and enjoyed the quirks of other cats such as Ms. Spider, Pepe, or Our Tom. When there is room at the food bowl, I go look for one who needs me, not one who reminds me. I think the only colors I haven't had are pure white or ginger.

But I do agree with the basic point- without them as a central point in my life it would be much harder to go on.

Georg December 22nd, 2006 11:49:00 AM

Stacy: I must be horrible, too. I cry more over the death of animals and children than I would for any adult human. It's the innocence factor. And no way could even a clone have the same personality as its genetic source any more than two identical twins would. But it's the best chance you'd ever get if you wanted to bet on a personality before birth. Finally, let me say that I would never advocate that people spend their money on $50,000 of cloned cat when they could donate the same to a shelter and save so many lives. But people do weird things when they're berieved, don't they?
Bettie: Thanks for the "carbon copy" comment--my boyfriend corrected me as well.

Dr. Patty Khuly December 23rd, 2006 08:17:00 AM

Stacy: No, cloned cats will not necessarily have the same coloration. CC, in fact, proved that point by her birth. She has a completely different fur pattern than her mother/self. And they most certainly won't have the same personality. Oh, if their original copy was very prone to sociability or aggression they might be more likely to exhibit those traits than the general population of cats, but even that's a stretch. There's just too much environment involved in attitude and personality. The only thing you get by cloning an animal is its twin, and no one would ever expect that human twins would be the same person. Why they think it of pets is beyond me.

Cloning of companion animals allows clueless owners who think they'll be getting the same animal that they adored previously to attempt a pseudo-resurrection, at the cost eliminating genetic variability. This is a recipe for disappointment that will result in more shelter animals...just now they'll all look the same.

Ugh. Don't get this former biologist going.

Becky December 27th, 2006 05:53:00 PM

Add Commment

Your Name:

CAPTCHA Verification