It’s time for Dolittler's Second Annual Pet Food Recall Awards!
(For the record, the First Annual Pet Food Recall Awards was kind of boring: Diamond Pet Foods swept in all categories. This year’s awards are far more exciting!)
The Insomniac Award
(for its round-the-clock work to prove that one in six animal deaths in a controlled setting really can be the result of a toxin in pet food and not the work of malevolent, pet-hating aliens):
And the award goes to…Cornell University! (OK so there’s always a shoe-in.)

The Artful Dodger Award
(for the most competent in evading individualized public scrutiny and for collectively keeping its well-guarded industrial secrets under wraps without suffering PETA protests and other hateful consequences):
And the award goes to…It’s a tie! What a great surprise! Every brand who outsourced production to Menu Foods wins a bronze urn emblazoned with the name or number of a dearly departed Menu Foods “test pet.” Guess what’s inside?

The Skinniest Man Alive Award
(for keeping his “cool” in the face of equal and opposite industry and public pressures):
And the award goes to… Mr. Stephen Sundlof of the FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine! I think he hasn’t moved in about ten days. Hey, you, Mr. Sundlof! Are you breathing?

The Careerist Award (for the most likely individual to win significant career advancement hot on the heels of the recall):
And the award goes to…Ms. Tuite, Menu Foods spokesperson! For keeping her cool and for single-handedly keeping the alien conspiracy theory alive, this individual is well poised to gain Federal government employment in the very near future. “What a talent!,” Mr. Rove has been overheard to remark. Could it be she’ll be on his payroll soon? I predict we’ll see Tony Snow fired for “performance” reasons in due course.
(Oops, I meant Sarah Tuite)
The Invisible Man Award
(for the most transparent display of faux emotion after the recall):
And the award goes to…The President and CEO of Menu Foods, Paul Henderson, for his “angry moment.” (To be fair, his anger may well spring forth unbidden from the mythical font bearing “omigod-my-career-has-gone-to-hell-how-will-I-ever-make-
payments-on-the-Porsche?” waters.)
Gosh darn it I just can't seem to download his picture. Here's a link, though.
The Gentle Giant Award
(for their proven consistency in the treatment, consideration and care of pets):
And the award goes to…China! Yes, the nation of dragons has proved, yet again, that an economy can evolve faster than the human brain! Potentially more effective than mass-clubbing (though certainly not as exciting), the [arguably “accidental”] distribution of banned rodenticides is a neat, passive-aggressive antidote to all those nasty American ideals. (Overheard at a Party party: “Can you believe it?—vermin in their living rooms and some say even in their beds!”) OK, so maybe I’m being unfair to China. Could it be they’ve changed their tune and simply want to cure our pets of cancer? †

The Best In Show Award (for the best and bravest recall reporting by a blog):
And the award goes to…The Pet Connection, for it’s sound (and restrained) reporting of the news and its brilliant method of amassing numbers of potentially affected pets. (Any blog that can make the big guys quiver in their corner offices gets my vote.)

And that’s all she wrote, folks. Please consider adding new categories of your own so that we might have an even more exciting round of awards next year!
† This award represents the blogger’s [perhaps irresponsible] conjecture on the [thus far] unproven mechanism of contamination of pet food with the known cancer-drug, methotraxate (AKA, the rodenticide, aminopterin). I mean, according to Menu Foods, the source has not yet been identified. (Could it be that aliens are still at large?) Give that woman another award!
Add Comment14 Comments
Dr Patty and loyal readers,
In this post pet food recall world, my mom has choosen to start feeding her geriatric (approx 19 y/o) cat a homemade diet. Above and beyond consulting her vet (which she has promised me she will do first thing tommorow) can anyone reccomend good websites that can provide reliable information regarding nutrition and recipes?
Thanks
Shannon
Shannon March 25th, 2007 08:42:00 PM
I don't have any suggestions for cooking for cats other than people really need to know what they're doing. Cats need taurine added to their diet. It's an essential amino acid that cats cannot produce themselves.
Stacy March 26th, 2007 07:14:00 AM
in response to recipes to cook for cats and dogs - get Food Pets Die For by Ann N. Martin. She has recipes in her books. Also I have started feeding my dogs home cooked food so they do not have to eat canned food again.
Ann March 26th, 2007 09:32:00 AM
OK so I, too, have started in on the home-cooked diet. I used basic proportions of protein to carbs and made a Sunday "must-gos" stew for the pooches with some frozen fish, frozen peas, frozen home-made meatballs, lentils, millet (I had some in my fridge for some odd reason) and whole-grain cous-cous. I then threw in some four-day old red sauce, withering watercress and seen-better days blueberries. Cottage cheese rounded it out. I left some fish raw and cooked the rest with the grains. I figure it should last the week in the coldest part of the fridge as long as I keep the raw fish component frozen. I guess I'll do this every Sunday night. The dogs "wolfed" it down. ;-)
BTW, was this post too political; for you guys? Too weird? Just wondering...
Dr. Patty Khuly March 26th, 2007 09:40:00 AM
With all due respect, Dr.Patty... that sounds really gross. Dogs don't care and why should they as they roll on dead things, but ick! LOL
Nah, not too political. I thought you handled it really well actually.
Stacy March 26th, 2007 09:51:00 AM
Too political? Nahhh.
I needed the laugh, and it was funny.
When do we get the big rosette.
Gina March 26th, 2007 10:31:00 AM
For Shannon who requested info on homemade diets for cats - this site http://www.catnutrition.org was recommended on a pet care list I read. I hope the info is helpful to your mother and her cat.
Susan March 26th, 2007 11:12:00 AM
Thanks, Heidi!
And Gina: You guys get a rosette AND a gold star. How about that?
Dr. Patty Khuly March 26th, 2007 04:40:00 PM
THIS IS NOT FUNNY - THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF US SUFFERING FROM PET LOSS OR HAVE PETS IN INTENSIVE CARE
Cate March 27th, 2007 01:49:00 AM
Cate, everyone grieves differently and reacts to the pain of loss differently. Sometimes a little wry humor can help a serious message resonate with people and diffuse angry feelings.
Take care,
Heidi
Heidi Schmeck March 27th, 2007 07:37:00 AM
Dr Patty,
Just a quick thank you for letting me use your forum to seek the help that I needed. All of the suggestions are much appreciated.
Shannon
Shannon March 27th, 2007 08:27:00 AM
Cate: Your point is not lost on all of us. But consider: Sometimes laughter IS good medicine. In my opinion, satire is an excellent avenue for political awareness among people who care--and a way to highlight the failings of those who don't. This battle needs to be fought on many fronts: by people like you who suffer losses and have to fight tooth and nail to get justice and by people like me who must find other avenues for change. They're equally legitimate, even if yours is more heartbreaking.
Dr. Patty Khuly March 27th, 2007 09:56:00 AM
Dr. Patty - don't forget calcium. You can grind up egg shells in a coffee bean grinder and add one half teaspoon per one pound of food. You are doing your pets a HUGE favor by making them a big batch of home cooked food. You'll be so happy with the results!
Judi
Judi March 27th, 2007 11:53:00 AM
Another really good book is The New Natural Cat by Anitra Frazier. This book is amazing and points out a lot of things I never knew about cats. Another good one is The Complete Guide to Natural Health for Dogs and Cats by Dr Richard Pitcairn.
Nicole March 30th, 2007 01:47:00 PM
Add Commment