Even vets need a night out every once in a while. Last week offered one of those. Unfortunately, it coincided with the same day I wrote about (again!) yesterday. So when I got myself showered and smartly dressed for a fancy dinner of CE credit-fueled high attendance, I wasn’t at the top of my game, to say the least. I drove myself to the steak-dinner event, nonetheless, knowing that continuing education is a cornerstone of good medical practice and meeting with vets in my community is essential to my profession’s well being.
This was an event hosted by our South Florida chapter of the AVMA (our national vet professional organization) and sponsored by a drug company to organize the details, source the speaker and make up the difference in the price of the steak, of course. Given the expense of taking forty vets out to dinner, our annual dues couldn’t possibly pay for such extravagance. So having a drug company sponsor the balance isn’t such a bad deal, now, is it?
Normally, I would say, “Nope. It could be worse.” At least the companies tend to bring in high-powered academic speakers who use the products and recommend them, but also have a way of delivering the lecture in a balanced manner. This was no such discussion. It was clear this speaker was dead set on his view of the science involved and wouldn’t consider any other way.
For the record, I’m a big proponent of one of the two products he was marketing, and a big critic of the other. Yet even his delivery of the science behind the former (Adequan) was as unbelievably distorted as to negate any potential support of the other (Derramax). I was floored—and angry.
Now, ordinarily, I don’t get mad in these lectures—I understand the basis behind any drug-sponsored talk. Ultimately, they want to sell me something. But, usually, I learn a little something along the way. Unfortunately, this one was just a sales pitch. Steak dinner or not, my dues were partially involved in paying for this event—and I was receiving academic credit for it, to boot! After the day I’d had, I guess I was feeling a tad intolerant.
To make matters worse, my questions were dismissed with an “I don’t understand whet you’re asking, Doctor.” And my colleagues were uncharacteristically silent. Later, we all agreed that the lecture hadn’t offered much in the way of academic value. At least I wasn’t alone in my oft-voiced opinions.
Sometimes I think I’d rather sit under the fluorescents in a McDonalds than suffer the skewed science of a drug-company sponsored sales pitch under the guise of “continuing education.” The wolf in sheep’s clothing, however, seems to trump all else in its ability to shore up attendance with the prospect of a good steak in a trendy nightspot. Somehow, though, there’s got to be a better way. Perhaps a night out after such a rough day had something to do with my outlook…
Add Comment7 Comments
At least you get a nice dinner in pleasant surroundings. I have 6 units to finish today in front of the old puter monitor. My last CE class outside was in the classroom space of a gym. Which sounds more enjoyable? I have to agree, though, that CE presentations put on by "vested interests" be they drug companies, insurance companies or other vendors can be very slanted.
Moira June 19th, 2007 12:23:00 PM
Well, look at it this way: your colleagues agreed with you. It always jacks me up to know that I'm not the lone dissenter on something.
Does anyone from the vet assoc. evaluate these speakers? If so, maybe this one won't curdle your dinner again. One can hope.
Gil. June 19th, 2007 12:58:00 PM
That dinner sounds bittersweet. And most likely, I would've lost my appetite.
Our CE classes (for Architects, mind you) are typically "lunch-n-learns" about windows, lighting, tile, stone, curtain walls, carpets and they are very focused and quick (because typically architects give off a very dicernable 'I don't want to be here, you've got 45 minutes. Where's my sandwich' vibe. The reps have praticed their schpeal to a T. I usually end up feeling awful for the reps due to my coworkers' level of rudeness.
But drugs / lives-on-the-line......that is an altogether different matter. And the wine-n-dine atmosphere is a little more creepy to me than soggy sandwiches from Panera Bread. It sounds very similar to the creepy feeling I get when I go to my doctor appointment and share the elevator with the buxom Blonde "pharmaceutical sales rep" chattering away on her celly, wheeling her briefcase, me wondering 'I wonder if my Dr. will prescribe what she's pushing'. Yuck.
I think you are navigating the murky waters well. It strikes me that you are open-minded to new meds/alternatives/methods while maintaining a healthy degree of scepticism for the information conduit. Keep up the good work Dr. Patty!
amy June 19th, 2007 05:51:00 PM
"It sounds very similar to the creepy feeling I get when I go to my doctor appointment and share the elevator with the buxom Blonde "pharmaceutical sales rep" chattering away on her celly, wheeling her briefcase, me wondering 'I wonder if my Dr. will prescribe what she's pushing'. Yuck."
*snickers*
Stacy June 19th, 2007 08:19:00 PM
Just curious: Do you think if you'd been wearing a suit and tie instead of a dress, your questions would have been taken more seriously?
Diane June 19th, 2007 08:46:00 PM
Dinae: One never knows but considering the speaker's Miami Vice outfit (T-shirt with slacks, complete with tacky, exposed gold chain) he clearly thought he was too cool for our school.
Dr. Patty Khuly June 20th, 2007 09:37:00 AM
Well, I dunno. Was it a real academic?
I've got a friend who was "on the circuit" for the large manufacturer of high-end antibiotics. I'm sure a lot of physicians walked out of those talks pretty pissed off, because what my friend was talking about biochemically was so out of left field as far as medical dogma is concerned that they must have thought he was shilling for the couple of drugs that he held up as still having any clinical relevance whatsoever. Whatever's "scientific" about practicing medicine is going to get slippier and slippier for a while before one can pretend to be certain about anything again. Lucky you!
Which isn't to suggest that your speaker was presenting the same sort of crisis of faith to your group. Odds are you just got a turkey. My suggestion is to band together with 7 good friends, commandeer a table far from the podium, and conspire to get tipsy and rowdy when you're given bad speakers.
[Kind of a scary time, isn't it, when one can so blithely type of nth-line-throw-everything-at-it-and-bring-in-the-firetrucks antibiotics, "the couple of drugs...still having any clinical relevance whatsoever".]
Thing One June 20th, 2007 11:48:00 AM
Add Commment