Has anyone else discovered the irony in Natural Balance’s botulism-tainted canned food? One of the recalled brands was the “Chinese Take-Out” version of their Eatables for Dogs. Who would leave that brand on the shelf after all we’ve been through?
Luckily, botulism isn’t known to be as big a toxin among pets as in our own bodies. In fact, there’s never been a reported case of botulism in cats. And dogs are remarkably resistant. One notable exception, however, is the ferret. They’re highly susceptible to the toxin.
Though humans are considered the big risk when it comes to this toxin, I’ve noticed that most people have no clue what botulism is or how it affects us. Beyond a tenuous grasp of the notion of botulism paralysis (thanks to the notoriety of wrinkle-easing Botox injections) and an innate fear of dented cans at the supermarket, what do you really know?
So here’s a brief primer:
Botulism is a rare illness caused by a nerve toxin produced by the bacteria, Clostridium botulinum. Because it can be fatal, docs tend to make a big deal out of it. This is especially true of the foodborne variety (where large numbers of individuals may be exposed). Infant and wound botulism are other forms of the disease but I won’t be addressing these.
Once a susceptible species has consumed the toxin (usually via contaminated food, but in at least one famous instance by injecting lab-grade botulism instead of the watered-down Botox), symptoms appear usually within 12 to 24 hours (though the incubation period varies as widely as 2 hours to 2 weeks). Progressive paralysis is the hallmark, but generalized weakness, difficulty swallowing and changes in vision is as far as some cases progress. It all depends on the individual’s resistance and the dose.
If it isn’t caught early, botulism can progress to paralysis of respiratory and cardiac muscles. That’s ultimately how it kills its victims. Respirators, cardiac drugs and other forms of supportive care are the mainstay of treatment, but antitoxin can be administered in the early stages—before the toxin has exacted its full toll on the nervous system.
For the record, I’ve never seen a botulism case. If I did, I’d probably assume the animal had rabies before considering botulism—it’s that rare in pets. But that doesn’t mean a big dose from eating several contaminated cans in a row won’t overwhelm an animal’s system and wreak its havoc.
While this scare hasn’t exactly done much to improve our confidence in the safety of our food source (human food was also produced by this manufacturer and was found to be contaminated as well), I haven’t heard of any pets coming down with botulism as a result.
I know we’re all scared—and justifiably so—but this seems a much more isolated incident than the wholesale ingredient contamination of the past few months. But as we all know, it ain’t over ‘till it’s over…
Add Comment6 Comments
It's somewhat of a relief to know that the incidence is so low, and that dogs and cats are relatively resistant to the botulism toxin. One of my dogs' favorite treats (and my cats seem to love it also) is a homemade version of the commercially-produced "Frosty Paws". The recipe calls for honey, and due to the dearth of information available, I decided to take the safe course of action and use only the pasteurized variety, as I simply wasn't willing to risk the health or safety of my pets. Even my own vet and a couple vet friends were unable to say with certainty that simple clover honey would be safe. I am fairly well versed in human and infant botulism, but was totally clueless as to the animal kingdom. Thanks!!
Shellie July 26th, 2007 08:56:00 PM
Doesn't the viscosity of honey prevent the botulism spores from growing, if they
are there?
Also, sufficient acidity keeps the spores from growing and producing the toxin.
This is supposed to be part of the reason that stomach acid evolved. I believe
that the danger of honey to small children or infants was that since their stomachs
don't have the high level of acid, then the spores can multiply in the digestive tract.
Since cats are so sensitive to so many other toxins, it seems like justice that they
can resist this one. There was an article I saw recently that said cats have no
ability to detect sweetness, which makes sense since they are obligate carnivores,
can make their own Vitamin C, so don't need to crave fruit for their health!
sj July 27th, 2007 01:24:00 AM
Even pasteurized honey is considered unsafe for children under 12 months. And I don't believe anyone's worked out whether it's the acids or a true immunological response that beats the spores found therein (based on my recent research).
Dr. Patty Khuly July 27th, 2007 05:31:00 PM
I didn't mean to imply that even pasteurized honey is safe for infants, as I know it is not. But for my 90+ pound dogs, in a recipe from a pet cookbook, I preferred to err on the side of caution. But infants or immunocompromised persons of any age should never be given honey.
Shellie July 28th, 2007 04:49:00 AM
I'm thinking that you are referring to the fact that the wheat germ, etc. came from China? At first I found it ironic that there would be a flavor called "Chinese Take-Out for Dogs," when dogs in China are on the take-out menu. ;)
"Has anyone else discovered the irony in Natural Balance’s botulism-tainted canned food? One of the recalled brands was the “Chinese Take-Out” version of their Eatables for Dogs. Who would leave that brand on the shelf after all we’ve been through?"
Brian July 30th, 2007 12:10:00 AM
good information
sem
search engine marketing
asdf June 1st, 2009 03:30:27 AM
Add Commment