Has anyone ever called you “cute”? Was it the kind of delivery that might have occasioned a barroom-style brawl should you have been gratefully relieved of all inhibition?
I got the “too cute and pretty” line the other day from a prospective agent I’d gifted with a sample of my writing and a headshot (they all want pictures these days).
Prognosis: Declined (I think).
Diagnosis: Too cute and pretty (or so they say).
Now that you’ve got the context I should tell you that while I may look pretty in pictures I’m more “interesting” in person. I’ll take “striking” (because I’m tall, I can understand that) or even “stately.” But “pretty”? Not so much. Factor in the adjective, “cute,” only two words away and I can hear that death knell in a deep slumber from across the country. I mean, no one in California should be calling anyone outside their state “too cute.”
So this begs the question: Should I wear glasses in my next headshot? Should I submit an alternate pic with mousy locks and my dorkiest pair of specs? No more highlights in my hair or vigorous lunchtime swims under the bronzing Miami sun? Maybe I should have a professional take my picture…instead of my boyfriend.
I think of pretty as a plus, generally. After all, you can always turn the volume down (think Charlize Theron in Monster—I mean wow). That’s what makes me think they just didn’t like my writing. Maybe they were just looking for a good way to give me the soft axe. (As if I’m so easily denied my right to experience appropriately stiff rejection by suffering an insult instead.)
Next time they should just come out and say it: Your writing style is sophomoric and self indulgent and your looks are at odds with your profession’s high level of respectability. Now there’s a statement I can take to the bank.
But here’s the rejoinder: Why can’t a professional have some cuteness to be credible? Look at celebrity chefs like that sexy spitfire, Giada de Laurentiis, or the syrupy Rachel Ray, not to mention the low-watt light bulb that is Sandra Lee (of half-baked fame).
Why can chefs, news anchors, actors, writers and other hard-working high-profile professionals be drop-dead gorgeous (or menacingly cute) while vets have to endure the expectation of frumpy-crunchy respectability in their appearance. Is there a mold we have to squeeze into before we can exit vet school and enter the sphere of credible professionalism?
Now look, I’m not complaining (not too much, I think) but it’s not as if I’m auditioning for the next big gig on Animal Planet (though I’ll take it if it pays well) I’m just trying to write a #$%& book. Use my high school yearbook photo if you need an ugly mug on the back cover—just publish me, darn it!
Add Comment14 Comments
So where is the "cute" photo of you????
Debbie Patrick August 24th, 2007 09:35:00 AM
Maybe they're casting for a veterinarian that resembles Dr. Ruth Westheimer?
Tatiana August 24th, 2007 09:51:00 AM
Personally, I think you should aim for the ' intelligent, funny and quirky yet beautiful' look. Oh wait - that's what you seem to have. Well, then maybe you should find an agent who is more in touch with the market, since I know I'd pre-order any book you publish. I mean, not all animal writers can look like Jon Katz...
Cindy August 24th, 2007 09:56:00 AM
Dangit, you should be able to do pretty much anything you want and be cute at the same time. And anyone that argues can take a pop in the mouth - which will probably take care of the "too cute" problem. ;)
CDC August 24th, 2007 09:57:00 AM
You're writing a book? Did you mention this before somewhere and I missed it? What's the book about? :)
Janine August 24th, 2007 10:55:00 AM
<snarky>I'm sure that agent has never been called "too cute and pretty"</snarky>
If the publishing world won't give you a break -
1. start video podcasting (the web being a medium which awards cute and pretty)
2. build up a following.
3. await the throngs of "not cute" agents begging to sign you.
Jonathan Spooner August 24th, 2007 10:58:00 AM
There outta be a law against calling any female over the age of 10, "cute". I'd describe you as fabulous, vibrant and beautiful - but "cute" - Never.
Margie August 24th, 2007 11:10:00 AM
Since I'm from a marketing background, it's my belief that this prospective agent wouldn't have been much help to you anyways.... he clearly doesn't "get" your appeal and wouldn't understand the target market for your writing. So what does he have to offer you?
Do I think you should have a professional photo done? Yes. (I was an art director once upon a time.)
Deanna August 24th, 2007 01:42:00 PM
Janine: *sigh* Yes, I'm writing a book but it's soooo slow bc I have to work 50-plus hours a week and take care of one reluctant back-to-schooler at the same time. It's the age-old career-change conundrum (even if what I'm after isn't an outright change, just a broadening of my activities within the profession): How do you get from point A to B without taking time off A to solve B. My credit cards can't finance me anymoe so some nice agent might be able to get me an advance so I can sit home 2 days a week and write research write. As to the book topic: Not to be cagey, but I'll tell you guys all about it soon--I promise!
Dr. Patty Khuly August 24th, 2007 02:09:00 PM
If the prospective agent was using that as an excuse when what he really wanted to say was that he didn't like your writing, then he doesn't respect you and that sucks.
If he really meant it, then he doesn't respect you and that sucks (particularly considering I have a very hard time believing that a man would be turned away because he's allegedly too handsome).
Either way I think it's clear that he was not a good match for you. Still frustrating, though.
I think a number of women on Animal Planet shows demonstrate that looks have f***-all to do with being a good vet or animal advocate.
For what it's worth, I too would pre-order any book you wrote...
Liz August 24th, 2007 02:16:00 PM
Too Cute!?? Huh?? I wonder if the agent in question tells prospective male authors that they are too handsome, or good-looking, or (insert adjective here) whatever? Who does this agent work for--The Ugly Press International?? I've never heard of such a thing. And, by the way, The Animal Planet thing might not be such a bad idea. I, for one, will not only pre-order any book you write, but would LOVE to see you on Animal Planet. You are intelligent and articulate, but down-to-earth; and attractive to boot. Sounds like a sure bet to me.
Shellie August 24th, 2007 08:38:00 PM
Or, you might just get the collegen injections in your lips and then emulate the Pantene girl in that deep-voiced pout: "Don't hate me because I'm beautiful." Just saying.
Cindy August 25th, 2007 12:25:00 PM
Be yourself! That's what makes you, you. Can't wait to hear more about the book! Looking forward to it.
Molly P August 25th, 2007 12:54:00 PM
Cindy: If I had more of a pout I'd look like the Jolie chick--no thanks!
Dr. Patty Khuly August 25th, 2007 11:04:00 PM
Add Commment