Even those occasional people we meet who claim to dislike cats intensely would agree: kicking them is wrong.
It’s pretty clear-cut. Most humans understand that hurting cats, even if you consider them “vermin” as many do, is a foul and unnecessary deed. So too, inflicting pain on rats, seagulls, pigeons and other creatures you happen to prefer not hang out with you in and around your home.
There are always better ways to deal with these animals than through violence, right?
Now, how about your girlfriend’s cat? Imagine you detest this animal. It would seem that, despite your irrational feline loathing, your relationship with your dearest would compel you to act honorably towards her beloved pet. It would seem…
…but not for New Yorker Joseph Petcka. Allegedly intoxicated, he kicked a 7.75-pound declawed cat to death after his girlfriend stormed out of her own apartment and left the two alone together.
She contends that Petcka killed Norman out of revenge when she ended her relationship with him earlier that night. Petcka claims Norman bit him, necessitating his admittedly harsh self-defense maneuvers.
The judge in the resulting legal battle urged jurors to “use [their] common sense,” after they repeatedly asked to have animal cruelty laws explained. Meanwhile, New York Post columnist Andrea Peyser stirred the pot mightily with a goading rant against those of us who would call for justice on Norman’s behalf.
“Felonious Ball of Fur Deserved Every Blow,” ran the title, quickly followed by her withering first line: “The stupid cat had it coming.”
I honestly don’t know what’s worse, someone who would kick a cat to death in a rage or the kind of person who’s willing to advance her shock-journalist career on the back of a dead cat…by implicating the cat in its own demise.
Either way, this story’s got everything any self-respecting animal lover loves to hate: a wronged animal, a hateful defendant and an obnoxious, parasitic journalist.
All I can add to the discussion is the obvious: kicking an animal to death does nothing to recommend a human to the rest of his society. Petcka deserves to be punished, even if it’s true that he was “overreacting” (as his defense attorney claims) with his steel-toed motorcycle boots…unless, of course, someone can convince me that this man’s life really was in some sort of mortal danger…from a seven-pound marmalade cat.
Add Comment29 Comments
OMG. This is even more depressing than the rest of the news these days. This nasty man's claim is SO bogus. The meanest cat I've ever met is no real threat to a grown human being; even a light shove with a foot would make the cat cower, at the very least; of course in reality, almost any cat alive would take off and hide at the first sign of real violence.
Even aside from known cat behaviour, and supposing there really was a house cat (of any size) that truly threatened a person, then wouldn't that person have, at the very least, lower legs covered with bites and scratches? What else could have constituted a threat on a grown man???
If he isn't punished (and unfortunately, even if he is), next time his rage is triggered, it will be his girlfriend (or her replacement--one hopes she wouldn't have anything to do with him after this) who gets beaten.
Judy October 7th, 2008 10:32:00 AM
Here's a site that chronicles the saga from the animal-friendly point of view. It includes links to all the information I've referenced:
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/ny-post-columist-...
Dr. Patty Khuly October 7th, 2008 10:38:00 AM
As mentioned by Judy above, don't forget that animal abuse is often a precursor to domestic violence. Viewed in that light, it takes on an even more sinister appearance, if killing cats wasn't sinister enough for you.
zandperl October 7th, 2008 11:59:00 AM
I dislike/am slightly scared of cats, and as you say I still think this is sick. I have a lot of rude words for this man, and that journalist...
Sian October 7th, 2008 12:02:00 PM
This is not just about Norman, bu every abused animal. There are those of us who are constantly fighting an uphill battle to educate people on animal rights. This writer has done a tremendous disservice to all animal advocates and the laws that they continue to try and pass to protect the animals, feral or domesticated. It is a FELONY to abuse an animal in this way, and the man should serve time in jail. The writer should be at the very, least suspended from her job with no pay. I wonder what would become of her if she wrote the same articles regarding a dog . How is kicking a cat to death any different then mutilating pitbulls for the sport? Please sign the petition below to have Andrea Peyser fired from her job as a writer for the NY Post. Tell the Post that we will no longer purchase the paper until we see action! Tell them to give the ASPCA a full page ad for free!
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/ny-post-columist-...
Dana Marcus October 7th, 2008 12:22:00 PM
That is just absolutely disgusting. I work with someone that admints his Dad taught him to kick cats as a child - some sort of sick manly deed. I hope the newspaper man is fired. What a sick perspective. One of our cats was found as a stray and we had to keep him away from the other cats for about 10 weeks to make sure he wasn't FELV positive. He had a good sized area but was stir crazy and did attack us a couple times but we could always get away from him if we needed to. In our case as soon as he was let out with the others he calmed down. I think a grown man can get away from a cat even if it is angry. That is just sick and wrong and I hope the jury convicts him of animal cruelty.
Jenny October 7th, 2008 12:44:00 PM
Apparently there was one holdout on the jury. The few jurors that were interviewed seemed pretty disgusted about the holdout. Who knows, paid off? a fan? animal hater?
There may be a retrial so it may be worth letting the DA know you'd support another trial
2CatMom October 7th, 2008 12:56:00 PM
When I first heard this story, it broke my heart, and still breaks my heart. I would give anything to be a judge handing out a sentence in a case like this. This guy would see the inside of a cell, no doubt.
I can also imagine the horrible feelings of the cat's owner, the feelings of guilt and responsibility she must bear.
Of course, most of all, the pain of the poor cat. Men like this need to be taken out of society. It makes me very upset that we even have to talk about the abuse connection to talk a jury or judge into doing anything -- the FACT that men like this also abuse women, children, other humans. If they don't now, they will soon. This is true. But we shouldn't NEED to say it to get something done. The cruelty to the cat should stand on its own.
I give credit to the National Enquirer on this one -- it's a rag, I don't buy it (no really . .. do I protest too much) but they broke this story and pretty much raved against this creep.
Peyser's job needs to go on the line for this one.
Stefani October 7th, 2008 02:05:00 PM
If my boyfriend had done that to my cat, he'd have more to worry about from me than a jury. A man that violent doesn't need to be around other people that could set him off.
ashleigh October 7th, 2008 03:00:00 PM
I have no particular fondness for cats in general. In fact, I actually loathe most of them. Still, kicking one to death is pretty messed up. I've had lots of issues with feral cats (there are lots of them - or at least used to be- where I live), and kicked at them/shouted at them/lunged at them to keep them from attacking my dog. It's not something I take pleasure in doing, it's more of and act of self preservation (and the fact that I'm not going to let the mangy tom cat that hangs out under the building take a swipe at my dog every time I take her outside). A cat, like pretty much any other animal, can be a pest, and I have no problem with a pest being humanely dispatched. And as for pests, I've shot more birds over fish ponds than I would care to count. Nothing I take particular pleasure in doing, but when they are eating away at your bottom line you've got to take action. That said, the line between pest and house pet is not a fine one. I've never come across a cat, even the meanest feral Tom, where I felt scared to the point that my only recourse was kicking it to death.
el Chupacabra October 7th, 2008 03:55:00 PM
How about this: let's leave the journalist and defendant in a room together. Let's see what happens if the journalist bites the defendant.
Kitty October 7th, 2008 05:08:00 PM
Misogyny and cat-hate are, in my experience, very tightly linked.
Laurel October 8th, 2008 05:37:00 AM
This story is sickening.
I will never understand the dog/cat hate social construct. To me, you either like animals or you don't. I understand having a preference for one or the other, but to actually HATE- that is indicative of something much more serious in my book. I agree that animal abuse is a slippery slope to human abuse and child abuse.
Creature of Habit October 8th, 2008 08:47:00 AM
Laurel and Creature of Habit are so right. I'd be immediately very suspicious of someone who "hated" cats; in my experience, they often hate women as well, and at the very least seem to have control issues. I am a cat person, I have cats, not dogs. But I love dogs too; I just already have cats, and am also gone from home way too often to be fair for even the most tolerant dog. Seems very strange to me that anyone could "love" one and "hate" the other...
Judy October 8th, 2008 01:14:00 PM
I first read about this on Zootoo. More recently was a story about 4 young children who broke a cat's back and then sodomized it with a butter knife. When asked they did this, they said they thought it was "cool." I almost cried over that article, and I definitely felt sick to my stomach.
robyn w October 8th, 2008 02:20:00 PM
Robyn: That is one of the saddest things I think I've ever heard of! I do not understand why people sodomize animals -- it's nasty and horribly wrong. Those kids, are going to grow up to be twisted individuals -- and when something like that happens and I were a judge I would order them locked up in a ward for a period of time and have them evaluated.
ashleigh October 8th, 2008 02:54:00 PM
How about exposing some veterinarians too? Everyone focus on animal cruelty but I have yet to read anything on veterinarian cruelty. It's just as serious, yet everyone tries to hide it under the carpet!
Fotini October 8th, 2008 04:58:00 PM
Robyn, that's a shocking and truly disturbing story. If I ever came across children hurting animals, I don't know that I would be in control of my reaction. There is not excuse, absolutely no excuse to harm innocent animals. Cruelty to animals is the lowest form of human existence.
Creature of Habit October 8th, 2008 05:01:00 PM
Let's all AGREE that companion animals are NOT MERE PROPERTY to kick around but SENTIENT PROPERTY! The law change will very easily take care of anyone RESPONSIBLE for harming animals!
Fotini October 9th, 2008 12:27:00 AM
Along the lines of hating cats: I find that many men are socialized to dislike cats. As in, men are meant to like dogs and women are naturally more cat-oriented. Another common implication is that gay men are the only males who truly enjoy cats.
I, personally, have a thing for men who love cats. My boyfriend keeps two kitties and sometimes takes some ribbing for it from friends who like to say things like, "There's something a little off about a guy who lives alone with cats."
Until our culture revises its feline-oriented beliefs with more inclusive, less stereotypical attitudes, I'm afraid many of our boys will also "learn" to consider cats less "manly" companions potentially worthy of "kicking around" a bit.
Dr. Patty Khuly October 9th, 2008 08:09:00 AM
It's one thing not to have an affinity or desire for a certain type of pet. But "worthy" of kicking? That's psycho, cruel, sadistic, and a totally different thing. I wouldn't consider that on a spectrum of understandable male attitudes even with our social stereotypes about cats=feminine, dogs=masculine.
The analogy would be - a guy who doesn't particularly like to hang out with women as friends (his prerogative) may also potentially find women worthy of being beaten up (criminal). I don't think those attitudes share a spectrum.
Stefani October 9th, 2008 08:53:00 AM
What a sick person.
Marjorie October 15th, 2008 05:28:00 PM
Ugh. Not that I ever had much respect for the NY Post, but Andrea Peyser needs to be canned. It goes to show anyone with an opinion, no matter how hateful & ignorant can wrire a column. I agree 100% with the others that abuse of cats is very much related to misogyny and violence. And too many men are told it's not "manly" to like cats and it is therefore more ok to commit these vile acts. In fighting abuse of animals, we need to work to educate people and hopefully destroy these dangerous mindsets. Thanks to the person who posted the petition site, I signed it. And thanks also for the clip of Sarah Palin. I already despise her, but it's interesting to know she's not much of a cat lover.
Donna December 9th, 2008 01:31:47 PM
I will still kick cats... Thanks for the terribly written guilt trip...
Igotaname13 February 1st, 2009 07:54:21 AM
Cats are usually assholes. They're animals just like you and me. Don't place blame on a man who wants to kick a cat's ass because it's being a dick. No one cares except for co-dependant people. It was asking for it just like any drunk bastard on the street is asking for it when he tries to pick a fight with someone bigger. It's just like you--you really don't give a shit about dying people across the world until someone presses you for it. Oh my god, you're totally against it when people ask you about it. Otherwise, it's just a passing thought while you preen your cats. You only care about you and yourself. The rest is just lies.
No way March 28th, 2009 07:51:48 AM
Transfer VHS to DVD Convert VHS
gtrte June 10th, 2009 04:12:04 AM
AVI to MOV MAC
dsf sdfsd July 23rd, 2009 02:41:12 AM
It was a very nice idea! Just wanna say thank you for the information you have shared. Just continue writing this kind of post. I will be your loyal reader. Thanks again.Ed Hardy
Ed Hard September 9th, 2009 03:37:57 AM
Thanks for your sharing.Maybe you are interested in Abercrombie and Fitch.
AF September 18th, 2009 01:06:13 AM
Add Commment