“Sometimes you just can’t legislate common sense,” is what some dog owners are saying in response to the driving safety legislation making its way through many states’ legislatures. Some of these bills would specifically ban dogs from riding in the driver’s seat with their owners. Others mention pets specifically among a list of ticket-able “distractions.”
Dog owners who take their pets out for some fast-moving fresh air and happen to live in New Hampshire, Illinois, Arizona and Virginia, among other states, may soon find themselves investing in doggie seatbelts and canine safety seats—or risk a ticket.
In September, California’s Schwarzenegger vetoed such an outright ban on dogs in drivers’ seats, claiming there was insufficient time to handle this bill with so many more important items on the table. Dubbed “The Paris Hilton Bill” for this heiress’ penchant for parading her pooches while driving, it garnered nationwide attention for its triviality.
But there’s no denying it—dogs are a distraction. And many ride unsafely (for them, anyway). In fact, I believe that allowing dogs to hang out of windows, feet perched on the frame (a common sight in Miami) is as sanction-worthy as transporting loose dogs in the back of pick-ups. I’ve seen severe injuries from both versions—and more than one DOA.
My dogs ride with me every day. They’re trained to stay off my lap and to stay in one spot while I drive. When I first pull out, they jockey for the best seat (which changes according to the weather, as I like to drive with the windows open). Then they settle. If Vincent’s especially fractious that day the seat belt is always in the car, at the ready.
Funny that my biggest concern in these cases has never been the driving. I’m always looking out for the dogs. I know that for their safety’s sake it’s best if my dogs are restrained. Not only does it keep them from becoming canine projectiles in the event of an accident, it makes it easier for rescue personnel to attend to me should the unthinkable occur.
As much as we might dislike any legislation that would serve to limit how we handle our dogs, perhaps some common sense rules would do us all some good. If nothing else, reading about these proposed laws has reminded me that my own could stand to suffer the indignity of buckling up. After all, I do every day.
Add Comment22 Comments
My dog wears a seatbelt every time we're in the car. I just use a harness that I got at Petco. It's comfortable and lined in fleece and the seatbelt buckles right through it. Also, he can wear it for general use when I'm actually at the pet store.
Really, seatbelts, car seats, or carriers just make good sense. I can't think of a good reason not to use them.
Tara November 22nd, 2008 08:44:23 AM
My uncle is a paramedic and he said that he has been to many accidents where the dog has actually decapitated the driver. He has also been to many accidents where the dog has been thrown through the front windshield and run over by the vehicle. Since hearing him describe these accidents I have purchased seat belts for both of my dogs and they wear them for about 3/4 or more of our car trips. Dog seat belts not only protect the animal but also the human passengers in the vehicle.
Laura November 22nd, 2008 08:49:28 AM
Here in Canada it is the same- your pets must be restrained by seatbelt or crate, or you risk a $200 fine.
Clover November 22nd, 2008 10:45:17 AM
The best investment I have is a car seat for Socks.. It gets hooked into the back seatbelt, and he gets hooked into it.. It's a great thing, as in the summer I drive a convertable, and winter the SUV.. One problem I have is I drop him off at my parents in the a.m. We live in NY, and in the winter it's too cold to put him in the back.. It's nice to know if I stop short, or am in an accident, he's as safe as can be expected.. He likes it, as he can see out..
barri November 22nd, 2008 11:55:51 AM
Besides the horrible scenarios already listed, consider the effects of powerful airbags, which we know are dangerous to children and even adults of very small stature. Most pets are below the minimum weight suggested for sitting behind a front seat airbag.
This is the reason that my cat rides in a carrier equipped with built-in seatbelt loops, BELTED into the center of the back seat. Yes, we listen to meows of protest all the way to the vet, but if she's meowing, we know she's still breathing. That is better than the possibility of being squashed by an airbag.
Miss Kitty's Mom November 22nd, 2008 11:56:50 AM
I've been told it took 9 years of lobbying & reintroduction of the bill (now law) to impose fine to allowing loose pets in the open p/u truck bed. I congratulate the animal welfare/societies that stuck with it.
And I believe there is a minimum requirement for shelter (dog houses) provided to outdoor canines/animals passed this past year, again I applaud the animal welfare folks!
Ironically, these very same animal welfare/lobbiests/societies have stood silent and turned blind eye to the knowledge of the practice of veterinary-administered "inhumane" death for money, mistakenly called *euthansia*, and I ask...simply one word...WHY???
"Pocket's Story from New Hampshire" http://clik.to/scotty
Barbara "Pocket's Story from NH" November 22nd, 2008 05:36:48 PM
Clover - It's not that way in every province, no law in Nova Scotia that requires you to have your dog in a crate or seatbelt.
Dr Khuly, I am very surprised to hear you do not buckle up your dogs. Having the seatbelt handy, hmmm how fast can you actually get it on your dogs should you be faced with an impending accident? You do buckle up your son I assume....
Elizabeth - From Nova Scotia November 22nd, 2008 06:06:25 PM
my dogs love to ride in the car. They wear special car harnesses that clip into the seatbelt just for that purpose. They are very well behaved even if I didn't clip them in, but if I had to stop short, I wouldn't want a small dog hitting the seat or dashboard and getting hurt.
the car doesn't move until everyone's seatbelts dogs, husband and kids/passengers alike at buckled in. Too many years on a rescue squad to be careless about that detail.
LorriM November 22nd, 2008 06:15:35 PM
My dogs ride loose in the back of my pickup. I do have a canopy so there's no chance of them jumping or falling out. I still worry some about them and what would happen in case of an accident, but two giant crates just don't fit under there. Luckily my state made 'unrestrained cargo' a serious offence about two years ago after a loose I-beam fell out of a truck and killed the driver of the vehicle behind it. Loose dogs count as unrestrained cargo too, but in my area at least, it doesn't seem like police are enforcing it at all.
lindabcs November 22nd, 2008 08:01:46 PM
Elizabeth: I have no excuse. It's a bad habit, keeping them unbuckled. I promise I'll go shopping tomorrow for Sophie's seatbelt and I'll start buckling them both in.
Oh--and in my car the front passenger's airbag is only supposed to deploy if there's someone sitting on the seat. I've been told that if the seatbelt light doesn't blink and scream at me when my dogs sit there it's because they're not heavy enough to trigger the mechanism (they weight 20 lbs each). Anyone know if that's true?
Dr. Patty Khuly November 22nd, 2008 08:15:00 PM
I just don't see this as Nanny-state stuff.
Yes, it's common sense that should not have to be legislated, but clearly -- based on what I see driving, and a few wrecks I worked when I still ran on an ambulance -- it needs to be. One can't legislate common sense, but one can use the force of law on people who don't exercise it and endanger others by their actions.
Unrestrained dogs, are in the case of a crash, dangers to the themselves, the human occupants of the vehicle, and emergency workers. If ejected, or if they bolt when a door is opened or a window breaks, they can cause additional crashes by running in traffic.
Dogs riding in the driver's lap -- or sitting on his shoulder, head, arm (yep, seen 'em all) -- are not just a hazard in a crash, they will cause a crash.
I'm against seat belt laws and helmet laws -- for humans past the age of majority. But belting in kids, restraining animals, goggles for motorcyclists -- these are legitimate areas for legal mandate.
Heather Houlahan November 22nd, 2008 08:42:40 PM
There's a wide variety of seat belt harnesses out there. I've not had much luck with the ones where the seat belt slides through the harness. Major PITA for me and the dog. Instead, I got a padded harness that has a D-ring. A short tab/traffic lead has the seat belt fed through the loop and the clip is on the harness. Metal clip, of course. Works great. I got this a number of years ago and, after a quick search, I see they've improved on it a lot with the prices staying fairly decent. As others have said, it's not just a restraining device while driving down the road. It's for when an accident does happen. The dog can't run away and get lost, dying alone from its treatable injuries. The paramedics don't have to have the dog shot because it won't let them near you.
We let a dog ride in the open bed of a truck once and only once. We had gone out of town and a friend kept him for us. However, he kept him in a pen with an un-neutered male goat. The two of them got along great (unusual for a male goat and a dog to get along). But oh did the dog stink! So in the back of the truck he went. He did great for the 1 mile trip to the house but as soon as it came to a stop, he jumped out. He scraped the bottom of his chin and jaw from tooth to throat. Road rash, basically.
PaulaO November 22nd, 2008 08:53:18 PM
I can see all of your points, and I really hate to see dogs on owners laps or perched with their front feet on the window, but at the same time I feel like there are exceptions. I have Great Danes and I drive a Honda Element. The seats are out in the back for the dogs and I have a barrier between the two front seats to protect us all. The barrier keeps them in the back for their safety and so that they are not a distraction to me while driving. But there is also no way to buckle them in back there and no crate big enough is going to fit in there. I think it's great that you all have these restraint devices, but for someone like me, the barrier I have is really the only option I have.
I also worry that if something like this is legislated that people will attach something to the dog's collar to provide restraint in the car. The poor dog could get serious whiplash even if the driver stops short at a corner...
Ingrid November 23rd, 2008 07:13:32 AM
Dr. Khuly my work is done for today! An ounce of prevention and all that...
Elizabeth - From Nova Scotia November 23rd, 2008 08:43:39 AM
Personal story here:
It was 6pm at the end of a very long and busy Friday, and I was looking forward to heading home. However, I was stuck at the clinic due to a very nasty car accident about 5 minutes from our clinic that had shut down the freeway. I'm sitting up front, chatting with a receptionist when a police officer opens the front door and his partner brings in a very dead and beat/cut up looking labrador. He was somehow involved in the accident, but the officers leave, promising to come back with more information. A quick triage later I call a code and the vet, who is down the block at the coffee shop. After intubating the dog and starting a central line (we had a policy at that clinic that unidentified animals in an emergency are treated like humans in an emergency-we eat the cost if we have to), giving drugs, CPR and shock doses of fluids, I manage to revive the dog in time for the vet to show up (at this point the receptionist, office manager, and I were the only ones there to handle the emergency). We x-ray the dog because it has awful lung sounds-one lung is collapsed and numerous ribs are broken. By 8pm we have a chest tube in, and are getting ready to transfuse the dog with universal blood from the receptionist's doggy, when the police show up. The lab had been an unrestrained passenger in the back of a woman's car-she had been exsanguinated by her own dog and died. The dog had actually passed through the front window of the vehicle and had been run over by another vehicle.
Sort of happy ending: The woman's son contacted us that night and told us to do everything possible to save the dog. He ended up getting transfered to a specialty practice for more blood transfusions, was eventually stabilized and underwent surgery to fix a broken pelvis and clean up the messy rib fractures. He had to have a lung lobectomy a week later due to necrosed tissue. He survived, and is doing well (I stayed in touch with the family). The bills totalled about 15 grand for the dog.
Bottom line: one life lost, plus 15k worth of medical debt. One single doggy seatbelt could've changed everything.
Morgan November 23rd, 2008 09:23:28 PM
Ingrid, have the buckle put back in the floor of the vehicle. There are tabs that have the "male" end to the "female" section of a seat belt. There is also one that uses a zip line that goes from one side of the vehicle to the other, overhead. Yes, the barrier keeps them away from you and it will keep them from flying through the windshield. But they can escape through a broken side or back window.
Google:
Petbuckle Travel Kit (has harness and buckle tab)
Auto Zip Line Seat Belt Harness (has harness, zip line, and buckle tab)
PaulaO November 23rd, 2008 11:17:18 PM
This is a great and timely post (with holiday travelling fast-approaching). Perhaps people could also include the links to sites that have the buckles/seats/harnesses they've mentioned?
CreatureofHabit November 24th, 2008 08:43:27 AM
This is by far the best seatbelt system I have used and I have tried several. http://usak9outfitters.com/autosafetygear.htm It even come in VERY large sizes.
Elizabeth -From Nova Scotia November 24th, 2008 09:51:28 AM
I would recommend the website, www.barkbuckleup.com. They test and rate the various safety restraint systems.
Jason November 24th, 2008 12:07:24 PM
Thank you for the links guys - very useful!
CreatureofHabit November 25th, 2008 08:26:35 AM
Thanks for your sharing.This is a good access to Abercrombie and Fitch.
AF September 16th, 2009 09:05:56 PM
Your article very interesting, I have introduced a lot of friends look at this article, the content of the articles there will be a lot of attractive people to appreciate, I have to thank you such an article. Khairuddin Syach Weblog and Mengembalikan jati diri bangsa
Mengembalikan jati diri bangsa September 29th, 2009 03:50:53 AM
Add Commment