This is the first Kentucky Derby I can recall not watching with bated breath—in fact, I didn’t watch it at all.
Like a junkie in withdrawal, I kept looking to my watch as it approached post-time, hoping a good book would prove sufficient distraction. I’d decided I wouldn’t be a part of it this year—or ever again.
Now, after the flurry of phone calls I’ve just received, you can be sure I won’t be tuning in to bear witness to its tragic conclusion. Though maybe I should—maybe we all should.
As no doubt you’ve heard, or seen first-hand, Eight Belles was euthanized on the track with bilateral fractures of her cannon bones’ condyles (at least that’s the news my vet surgeon consultant had access to at the time of this posting).
One leg is devastating enough, as in Barbaro’s case. Two carries a mandatory a death sentence—and requires it be carried out on the spot. At least the horse racing industry has a heart when it comes to killing its critically wounded competitors. Too bad there are so many of them…
Make no mistake: Horse racing is the most dangerous sport in the world—for the athletes involved. Short of high-stakes mountain climbing, in which humans take huge risks after assessing their own personal outlook on mortality, the "Sport of Kings" wins out when it comes to the athletes’ death toll stats—but without its competitors’ willing compliance.
Take Barbaro. His recent example proved two things:
1-To those who might otherwise have neglected to add up the fatalities, Barbaro proved to millions that horse…racing…kills…horses.
2-The casualties of this sport are lauded for their “heart,” conveniently shifting the emphasis on the crime’s perpetrators (the industry and all of us, its fans) to the glory of the animal—thereby fueling more Triple Crown fandom…and occasioning more deaths.
How sick and twisted is our culture that Barbaro’s legacy (apart from the excellent research into laminitis his prolonged hospitalization facilitated) has become one where the celebrity of the horse’s agony made for a bigger box office draw at the killing of another?
I think I’ll always be ambivalent at the sight of horses streaking down the track. I can’t help but catch my breath at the hammering of hooves and a glimpse of sweaty coats over rippling musculature. Like many among you, I grew up on this kind of equine athletic display.
But with equine genetics pushing animals further into a red zone where just pulling up might mean catastrophic injury, there’s no reason for me to subject myself to the needless slaughter first-hand. I’ll not expose my son to the gladiatorial gore, either. No, thanks, I’ll take my comments off the air from now on.
As you must be too, I’m beyond disgusted by what happened today. That’s why this filly should serve as more than just another needless cautionary tale in the annals of horse racing. It advances a moral imperative to us, her fans, and most of all, to the industry itself: Reform. Fast. Or. Die.
If this tragedy had to happen, all I can say is that I’m glad it happened on the industry’s most “glorious” race day. There’s nothing like a conspicuous catastrophe, without a protracted agony like Barbaro’s and its obligatory spin, to bring the real meat of the issue to the fore: Horse racing as it’s currently practiced is not a sport for animal lovers.
Barbaro’s death was enough for me…will Eight Belle’s be enough for you? If so, I’ll ask you just one favor: Boycott the Triple Crown...at least until the industry responds significantly to the need to reform its practices. That’s not so hard after what you saw today…is it?
Add Comment35 Comments
Horses may have enough heart to run themselves to death, but humans should have enough brain to not let them do it... Why do they run these babies so young? :(
Megan May 3rd, 2008 11:04:00 PM
I wonder if the fact that she came in second and THEN died will give anyone pause.
zandperl May 3rd, 2008 11:20:00 PM
Yep, I'm done with it. No joy in racing for me.
Especially after spending much of today with a lovely yearling filly. I can't imagine someone RIDING a horse that young, much less asking her to work under saddle at speed.
Stacey May 3rd, 2008 11:44:00 PM
The horse I usually ride is a 7 year old gelding, and he's a young guy with over a decade of work left in him. Why on earth do owners think it's okay to even put their horses out on the track before they're four or so? Let them grow up and develop soundly before putting them to the test.
lindabcs May 4th, 2008 12:49:00 AM
It was an obscene spectacle. The fact that it happened during all the ostentatious pomp and circumstance of the Kentucky Derby only made it more so.
I may be an optimist, but I hope this tragedy, following so closely on Barbaro, will really turn people off horse racing.
We won't be able to eliminate it completely, buy maybe public outrage will shut down the gambling aspect and drain much of the money out of it. Maybe then we can "put down" the funny hat wearing, mint julip swilling, silly song singing, millionaires that push these poor animals to their deaths.
Larry May 4th, 2008 02:56:00 AM
Yes, it is enough. I will never watch a horse race again.
I don't know why Ruffian or Go For Wand or Union City or Prarie Bayou or Barbaro or any of the others never stopped me from watching horse races, but this filly is enough.
I've watched the Triple Crown and Breeder's Cup races since I was a kid--watched Secretariat. I never paid to see a race. I never paid attention to who sponsored them. I like the think the industry never made a dime off me. But I could be wrong, and I can't bear to look anymore.
And whenever we do have a Triple Crown winner again, I don't think I'll care very much. I don't htink I'll do anything but wince, maybe tear up, and think about what that title costs the horses of the world.
Laurel May 4th, 2008 07:04:00 AM
I couldn't agree more. What kills me is that they - the owners, the trainers, the vets - always say, "there was no choice." Actually, there was. They just happened to make it long ago when they decided to run this beautiful, majestic animal for sport in the first place. To me, there is nothing more self-indulgent in sports than horse racing. Watching these magnificent animals become so incredibly vulnerable at the hands of human beings truly breaks my heart. And it's time for a change.
KSA May 4th, 2008 07:16:00 AM
I totally agree with your article. I did not watch this race after the Barbaro tragedy. I only pray this filly's death will highlight the multiple issues these thoroughbreds are exposed to. Racing must be safer for them but will it. If death is an "unfortunate " possibility for these horses as the fillly's trainer expressed, would we say the same thing about human sport?
peggy james May 4th, 2008 09:24:00 AM
I had a feeling this might happen, specifically to her. When I heard on the radio that a filly was running, I thought "Wow, they will be pushing her SO hard . . . to prove that she can beat the boys, and make history . . . "
Of course they push all the horses hard. And it is tragic -- how could she have kept running with that injury? Yet, she made it acorss the finish line, second. She paid out for them.
It's obscene and disturbing.
I didn't watch, couldn't watch. My mom did and called me in tears. She had horses as a child and loves them, maybe more than dogs. She wanted to know what we could do.
I said: "Well, we could go protest next year . . . " But those rich a-holes won't care, they will laugh in our faces and have another mint julip.
Or . . . we could commit to helping a horse rescue. I keep coming back to that. A place where they retire horses from this sport -- horses whose sperm isn't still making them millions in stud fees.
Stefani May 4th, 2008 09:46:00 AM
A good friend of mine, Alex Brown, runs a busy site dedicated to honoring the legacy of Barbaro and improving horse welfare. There is much discussion on the forums there of Eight Belles's plight.
http://www.AlexBrownRacing.com
Alex May 4th, 2008 11:06:00 AM
As I just said over on Pet Connection, I stopped watching horse racing after Barbaro. This is ANIMAL CRUELTY plain and simple. If I brought a pet to you Dr. K with two broken front legs I think I would have a bit of explaining to do. And if I told you, 'she just ran after that mouse - she wouldn't stop until her legs went out" - I think I'd next be explaining myself to the police. And rightly so.
A major boycott is in order. Most people don't follow racing - just the big 3 races. And the sponsors are some of our major corporations. I'm going to see if there is a petition over on The Petition Site or Care2. If I do, I'll post the link. If not, I may just put one together myself.
2CatMom May 4th, 2008 11:43:00 AM
Personally I have not had much to do with the horse industry since the early 1980s. However, my heart broke hearing about the race yesterday--especially after I had read the post over on Pet Connection...prophetic or predictable?
So, I am glad to read your post and only hope that people do boycott. Hitting the industry in the pocketbook is one of the ways to make and point and implement change--change that is long overdue.
Diana L Guerrero May 4th, 2008 12:07:00 PM
I don't follow horse racing but yesterday I tuned in, mostly because I couldn't find anything else to watch. I have loved horses for as long as I can remember and have been riding since I was four years old. I'll take any excuse to watch this magnificent athlete, live or on tv.
When I tuned in to the Kentucky Derby yesterday, I did so with conflict in my heart. As I watched the horses all prance onto the track I thought about how dangerous this was for them and how if their owners and trainers really loved them they wouldn't push them so hard. I looked at all the ridiculous women in the stands with their stupid hats, that have probably never even set foot in a barn, mucked a stall, or brushed a horse, and it made me angry.
And then she died.
I feel guilty for even watching. Never again.
When I worked around Standardbreds (harness racing) we let the horses grow up before they raced. We also jogged them around the track a couple of times before a race to let them warm up. While I know that harness racing isn't perfect, and can still be dangerous, this just makes a whole lot of sense to me. All horse lovers should boycott this sport.
Meghan RAHT May 4th, 2008 12:12:00 PM
Do you know all competitors in the Kentucky Derby this year go back to Native Dancer in pedigree? They breed with an emphasis on one quality, and body structure for long term soundness is not one.
Even if these horses were not killed on the track, what about those whoa re too slow, come up slightly lame, have chronic lameness issues, or just don't win the purses? These get dumped on the market and often have not 'come down' from the track- they are often high strung, nervous, not easy to handle, have obvious or chronic lameness issues, and they only know the track. The males will ALL be stallions- which makes them less desirable for most people wanting a riding horse.
If we make horse slaughter easier in the US, we are making the byproducts of the horse racing industry easier to get rid of,.. they can make a few hundred getting rid of their 'byproducts' rather than having to find other solutions.
Another reason I'm all for the banning of horse slaughter. Let the industry self-regulate their economic issues.
jenni May 4th, 2008 12:27:00 PM
Money is what keeps this business going, and money is the only thing that will get their attention. One thing that would help would be to change the tax structure. Why should these owners be allowed to use horse farms as a tax shelter?
If you took away tax incentives for breeding and racing horses, I think you would see a lot of these so called horse lovers get out of the business real quick. Taking the profit out of racing could only help the horses.
I like your statement; Horse Racing Kills Horses. That would make a great bumper sticker.
Mary May 4th, 2008 01:28:00 PM
Will racing horses with whips for profit finally be exposed as and reduced to the enslavery that it is??
Will animal cruelty charges EVER be considered??
I am still appalled and horrified by what I witnessed yesterday. I cannot support or watch this most inhumane, "sport," again. I will join you and not watch this happen again and again...Ruffian, Barbaro--now THIS??
UNACCEPTABLE!
This practice of racing horses sickens me.
One Disgusted RN May 4th, 2008 02:53:00 PM
It just occurred to me that the closest 'sport' to horse racing is dog fighting. The animal is 'bred' to do one thing. And the owners of both animals say the animal wants to do this. And the death of the animal is an 'unfortunate', but not infrequent end result. and its all driven by $$.
Perahps the only difference is the 'class' of the person participating in the sport, along with the bad hats.
I really, really, dislike PETA, but I hope they make a big stink about this one.
2CatMom May 4th, 2008 04:18:00 PM
I was just having a conversation will one of my vet school classmates as I pulled up this article. Both of us have had horses since early childhood. Neither of us can stomach the idea of going into the commercial horse industry- and this just brought the point home.
Would it really cost that much to let these horses stay at pasture for another year and allow them to develop more before putting so much strain and pressure on their bodies? Considering that some of them start racing before they are actually 2 (they are considered 2 by they governing body on Jan. 1 the year their second birthday will be in, but they can be as young as a year and a day), is it any surprise that so many break down? Most of the time pleasure horses don't start their training until age two, let alone competition.
Alli May 4th, 2008 05:38:00 PM
Help me out. I want to have some expert vet on racing these horses. I hate what happen yesterday. I am not activist by know means, but I just can't stand to see to seee that happen if it could have been prevented. That is my questions to all of you. Was this just a terrible accident like a young man having a heart problem or is there a great risk with these horses?? Horse racing happens all the time. Do we have stats on death of these horses? I like to know if anybody has that info
kurt May 4th, 2008 05:54:00 PM
It's not just racing. Four horses have died or been euthanized due to injury at high-level 3 days event competitions within the past month (Red Hills in Florida and Rolex in Kentucky).
Sarah May 4th, 2008 08:49:00 PM
kurt: Dr. David Nunamaker, one of my professors at the New Bolton Center at the Univeristy of Pennsylvania (where Barbaro was treated), reported that "[Horseracing] is more dangerous than any sport you’ve ever heard of." His studies show that 1.5 out of a thousand race starts result in a catastrophic [usually life-ending] injury.
Dr. Patty Khuly May 4th, 2008 08:54:00 PM
A little off track, but does anyone know what they do with most racing greyhounds when they retire now? I know some go for adoption -- but surely not all of them or the rescue organizations would be flooded. Are most of them still euthanized?
ashleigh May 5th, 2008 07:42:00 AM
Ashleigh: I don't know the stats but some are also sold to canine blood banks where they are reportedly very well treated.
Dr. Patty Khuly May 5th, 2008 08:48:00 AM
We have now witnessed two fatal injuries in two of the most watched races in the country..Barbaro in 2006 in the Preakness, Eight Belles in the Derby 2008, and thought not fatal,a devestating injury to Charsimatic in the 1999 Belmont......How many more of these horrific events do we not see on national TVand how many more to we need too see before there is a call to action!
In the National Football League, itself a dangerous and rough arena, rules and equipment are constantly updated to protect its players....Where is the mind of the racing association?????????Is it engulfed by greed and tradition? We should boycot viewing and attending all races until the tracks(synthetic surfaces have proven safer) and rules(fillies versus colts) are changed!
khw May 5th, 2008 11:09:00 AM
A lot of practices in the horse racing industry are indefensible--they do race them too young, the exclusive focus on speed in breeding has led to weaker horses compared to those of years past, etc. But it should be pointed out that largely as a result of the publicity surrounding Barbaro, the industry is making changes. It will take time, but it is happening, and hopefully some of the awful statistics can be remedied. The growing number of synthetic track surfaces is one such sign of change.
regina May 5th, 2008 12:40:00 PM
As long as people make money there will be racing....I will not be apart of it though. My last straw was Barbaro.
Rika May 5th, 2008 07:19:00 PM
I really appreciate your well thought out perspecitve on this tragedy. I have been an avid horse racing fan over the years. Considering I am also very concerned with animal welfare, it always felt like my dirty little secret but I tried to justify it away by saying that horses want to run and that's what they been bred to do. But after watching what happened to Eight Belles (and remembering Barbaro's prolonged suffering) and then breaking down sobbing for the rest of the day...I can now confirm that I will be joining you in boycotting the Triple Crown. Realistically, horse racing probably isn't going anywhere. But something has to be done...even if smaller compromises regarding raising the age of horses that race or looking into artificial turf that isn't as hard on their fragile legs has to be done. There was no need for that amazing filly to suffer and I hope it has made as huge an impact on the public at large as it did on me. :(
Kerrylyn May 6th, 2008 04:27:00 PM
I can't thank you enough for your heartfelt, conscious, moral insights into the dirty industry of horse racing. Having close connections to those involved in the industry, I learnt first hand the barbaric practices employed, exploiting the horses to abusive extent for one thing alone...profit.
The killing of Eight Belles has made many of us genuinely heartsick since the first Saturday of May. Those on some horse racing blogs, out for fast, easy money, the new American way... wealth without work, are unconscious and oblivious to the extreme danger these magnificent creatures are subjected to.
I am thrilled with the campaign PETA has launched demanding much stricter standards for the racing industry, and ultimately, to abolish horse racing completely. The Thoroughbred can be used for eventing and other purposes, and is a breed so incredible that they should be more sacred to our culture than certain animals to others. Instead, they have been chronically exploited, and literally run into the ground.
The culture of "get rich quick" folks need to find their way. Either they 're living beyond their means, or are addicted to gambling. Race horses, per se, should not be exploited for the gains of said culture, or the phenomenally wealthy who amuse themselves at the expense of a living creature.
As the fox said to the Little Prince, "It is only with the heart that one can see rightly. What is essential is invisible to the eye." It is time for the race horse ghouls to take heart.
SFisher May 6th, 2008 07:29:00 PM
"I am thrilled with the campaign PETA has launched demanding much stricter standards for the racing industry, and ultimately, to abolish horse racing completely. The Thoroughbred can be used for eventing and other purposes, and is a breed so incredible that they should be more sacred to our culture than certain animals to others. Instead, they have been chronically exploited, and literally run into the ground. "
SFisher, PETA's goal is not the reform or abolition of horse racing. PETA's goal is the abolition of domestic animals. They've said so, quite directly. They're not feeling grief for the tragedy of what happened to Eight Belles; they're dancing a jig because it's an emotional event that they can exploit.
Okay, third try on the stupid letters. And want to emphasize _stupid_, because the first two offerings included one letter, the last, that was so far off on the right-hand side that it was less than half visible. And, yes, I will continue to comment on this every _single_ time the always egregiously bad design of this "security" feature goes off the cliff into unusability.
There are serious problems in horse racing, major problems that are hurting the individual horses and the thoroughbred breed. Fixing those problems, though, is not what PETA is about. PETA is about teh _extinction_ of horses, and dogs, and cats. and cattle and sheep and pigs, too. Everything that doesn't live wild and away from human beings--oh, wait,they're for the extinction of feral cats, too.
Lis May 7th, 2008 12:18:00 AM
Most keen fillies will run their hearts out,and eight bells did this down the stretch. she was whipped in excess by her jock. His actions caused her to wobble which broke one cannon bone and then when her 1.300 weight shifted to the other leg, it broke also. How much faster did he think she could run? She ran brave and strong--Good Grief. Then the trainer says" She ran the race of her life" , with a tear in his eye. Yes she did and the race of her death.
Too young, Steriods (17 hand filly on fine legs) Big Brown 2 3/4 yr old colt running on cemented feet and needle "trainers"
Grand colt (Bi g Brown) 2 1/2+ that finished first across the line but he has 2 quater cracks in the front and maybe his hooves won't shatter. Will I watch him next time on the track. No. I'll wait for the a.m. news and if it's another death I can turn away. Use and abuse.
This has to stop. The good minded people of this country have had enough.
lady page May 7th, 2008 04:51:00 PM
Lis writes: "PETA's goal is not the reform or abolition of horse racing. PETA's goal is the abolition of domestic animals. They've said so, quite directly. They're not feeling grief for the tragedy of what happened to Eight Belles; they're dancing a jig because it's an emotional event that they can exploit....There are serious problems in horse racing, major problems that are hurting the individual horses and the thoroughbred breed. Fixing those problems, though, is not what PETA is about. PETA is about teh _extinction_ of horses, and dogs, and cats. and cattle and sheep and pigs, too. Everything that doesn't live wild and away from human beings--oh, wait,they're for the extinction of feral cats, too."
PETA has outlined a list of criteria submitted to Chairman Robert Beck, Jr. which, if you care to research, does't begin to approach the statements you've made about PETA's stand on horse racing. If you can provide verifiable links and research that support your argument, I'll be interested to read them. PETA is against factory farming, fur farming, animal testing, and animals used for entertainment purposes, and is also against the chaining of backyard dogs, which is more than understandable. Nowhere does PETA claim to be advocating the extinction of horses or any other breed of animal. What PETA opposes is "specieism" and the excessive inbreeding as found in Thoroughbreds, which often leads to fatal neurological problems, as was the case with "With a City" a few years ago. This does not mean they advocate the extinction of horses.
By no stretch of my imagination am I able to understand what ideas you entertain about PETA. The organization may at times seem radical, but their best interest is surely not in "dancing a jig" because of the emotional event Eight Belles was killed because of. PETA, as other conscientious organizations, seeks to end the casualties on the race track, like that of Eight Belles, Barbaro, and countless others, recently and in the past, who have been the victims of irresponsible and greedy trainers, owners, and jockeys, as well as the betting public out to make a fast, quick, fat, buck....all the easy way, and at the expense of horses.
People advocating animal rights are accused of being "bleeding hearts," and so on. Better to have a bleeding heart -- than no heart at all.
SFisher May 7th, 2008 07:52:00 PM
My, My--- So many opinions so little real knowledge of the horse.
Fillies will run their hearts out. Good fillies are more keen than their brothers. Whipping this filly more than 4 four times down the stretch was abuse. She was running second with all her heart. Did the jock believe that abusing her would make her overcome Big Brown? No way could she overcome his performance, so why couldn't Eight Bells jock settled for second place and be kind to her???
Broke both front legs
, the first crack came down the strech, the leg broke after the finish line and then the off leg couldn't support the weight and broke.
2 ,3/4 year old Steriod induced muscle bound 17 hand filly!!! Running on pen thin legs.
Owners, breeders, needle trainers , high tax bracket people must be accountable for the deaths, and the cripples that they produce yearly. PETA isn't my ideal however I'm leaning in their direction when it comes to the racing horses. My youngest, is a excerise rider and has real bad stories to tell about the Throughbred racing people.
lady page May 9th, 2008 06:32:00 PM
My, My--- So many opinions so little real knowledge of the horse.
Fillies will run their hearts out. Good fillies are more keen than their brothers. Whipping this filly more than 4 four times down the stretch was abuse. She was running second with all her heart. Did the jock believe that abusing her would make her overcome Big Brown? No way could she overcome his performance, so why couldn't Eight Bells jock settled for second place and be kind to her???
Broke both front legs
, the first crack came down the strech, the leg broke after the finish line and then the off leg couldn't support the weight and broke.
2 ,3/4 year old Steriod induced muscle bound 17 hand filly!!! Running on pen thin legs.
Owners, breeders, needle trainers , high tax bracket people must be accountable for the deaths, and the cripples that they produce yearly. PETA isn't my ideal however I'm leaning in their direction when it comes to the racing horses. My youngest, is a excerise rider and has real bad stories to tell about the Throughbred racing people.
lady page May 9th, 2008 06:33:00 PM
Lady Page -- Your sharing is important to all of us who are traumatized by the tragic death of Eight Belles. You obviously have a bird's eye view of the racing industry. Several years ago I had a client who owned several race horses in Kentucky. The abuse of the mares, foals, colts and fillies, and what I learnt of the breeding and training process to this day makes me heart-sick to think of. Regardless of a mare's age or physical condition, she is sometimes literally bred to death. Sometimes the birth can be so complicated that the foal can only be removed with a tool called a "comealong." Hormones and drugs are used excessively, causing ongoing and irreversible complications in the mares and foals that can only be remedied with more drugs.
I'm sure your youngest could write a book about the abuses of the horse racing industry. It's time someone writes one.
SFisher May 9th, 2008 10:40:00 PM
i grew up watching cigar win the breeders cup, followed silver charm's every move. my life has been dedicated to horses and so, a few years ago after finishing college i began working horses at monmouth and philadelphia parks. galloping thoroughbreds, hitting speeds of 45 mph, feeling like the wind... whatr could be better? as i got deeper into the whole thing, i became utterly disgusted. trainers were shooting horses up with opiates, pumping lasix into them, patching them together so they could enter one more race, get one more check. Thats to say nothing of the mental abuse these animals suffer. Anyone who thinks its ok to keep a 1200 lb animal (who naturally roams 20 to 30 miles a day in the wild) in a 10ft x 12ft box for 23 hours a day is a lunatic. I was told to start horses only a year and half old... at that age their bones are not fully ossified.. meaning they are still packed with cartalidge that has not yet turned to bone. these animals are bred to break. The modern TB has terrible feet and lower leg structure. and its not just racing. almost every equestrian sport in the world starts animals too young and practices overbreeding and inbreeding. look at the western practice of breeding super beefy quarter horses with terrible hooves and lower leg structure, starting quarter horses at 2 years or age. you're setting yourself up to own an animal that is injured and washed up by age 5. i am also a biologist and im telling you, these animals do not mature FULLY until age 6. they should not be engaged in any mounted high stress perforance events until age 5. they should not be ridden AT ALL until age 3, and very lightly in the first year, with the focus on ground work. i have since left the racing industry and focus on vaquero and natural horsemanship colt starting but am still constantly dissapointed in how little people know about these beautiful and complex animals they "own." The fine art of a man-equine relationship is all but lost in this age of profit and quick fixes. perhaps one day we will learn to ride again.
ponygirl June 8th, 2008 09:56:00 PM
Add Commment