A veterinary blog for pet lovers, vet voyeurs and the medically curious...
Support Dolittler: Subscribe!
Search

Speed demon surgeons may not sound like your pets’ best friend, but let’s not be too hasty now…sometimes it really is the best medicine.

In some surgical residency programs they teach the mantra, “time is trauma under anesthesia.” In other words, the longer a patient is out, the higher the risk of complications.

And statistically, that’s true. The longer a pet is under anesthesia the higher the rate of anesthetic complications and infections.

But what about a surgeon taking their time? Isn’t that what we really need them to do?

No doubt many delicate procedures require triple-checking and a deft set of hands. And every surgeon’s got their ideal pace. What seems like “rushing” to one surgeon may be the standard operating procedure of the next. And it may seem to you that the more cautious surgeon is the more competent one…but not always.

Imagine you need a bleeding spleen out of an abdomen—fast! Without the speed, skill and, yes, sometimes recklessness, to make that happen, our patients may die. Gunshot wounds, hit-by-cars, bleeding masses—all of these require SPEED.

Remember the post I wrote on the Guinness Book of World Record seeking vet with a goal of neutering fifty cats in a few hours’ time?

Some of you were horrified by the glorification of surgical speed over proficiency and quality. But speed doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice quality—not always, anyway.

Slow when you need to be, fast when you don’t. That’s what I was taught. When you do and when you don’t is a judgment call every surgeon has to make—and that takes experience.

Then there’s the issue of practice: If you’re never practicing your speed, how can you ever recall it when you really need it?

My take? I speed-demon the most routine elements of routine procedures, especially the stitching. This helps to keep up my speedy skills for the horrible emergency cases unable to afford a veterinary surgeon’s skills and experience. I also knit fast to keep my fingers nimble—it helps.

Sure, I only see about one crazy surgical case a month but if the Speedy Gonzalez in me isn’t ready for it I might as well pull out the euthanasia solution on some of these cases.

There are trade-offs in every line of work for every single skill we might ever seek to master. Speed and caution may seem like they qualify as trade-offs but rest assured, sometimes that speed-demon surgeon really has your pets’ best interest in mind.

Comments
I feel you miss the tone and focus of those responses. Being quick is not what rubs the wrong way, but aspiring to be quick for its own sake and actively inviting pressure to be as quick as possible. Even if very incorrectly, this suggests to the casual reader a willingness to be quicker than is necessarily optimal for the animal. I personal do not think operation 'racing' should be encouraged, for several reasons including that the best speed of operating for the animal is an optimum not a minimum (or a maximum). In any case, it just isn't going to play in Peoria.
# Posted By emily | 5/16/08 1:35 PM
The problem isn't a good vet trying to keep up on his/her emergency skills. The problem is places like Banfield where the vets are mediocre at best and have "time allotments" that each surgery spays and neuters alike are to take....
Then there is the generalized ego fest that can occur when bragging rites take over higher brain functioning....
My vet neutered 6 of my kittens on tuesday. I don't care if it took him 20 minutes or 3 hours. I care if he did the best job he could. That's what I pay for. It would be more critical that that spleen comes out in 10 minutes but then the next day so do the animals intestines through sloppy suturing than it take a little longer and done correctly. Twice under anesthesia is worse than once twice as long.
It's a practice that shouldn't be encouraged or glorified.
# Posted By LorriM | 5/16/08 3:10 PM
I'm not a big Banfield fan, but every vet has time allotments for surgeries. You've got to be able to schedule things somehow. The practice I work in during school holidays bases them on weight/procedure. Large dog spays take longer than small dog spays. I'm willing to bet than BF vets don't get to the end of the time allotment, say "Oh shucks, I'm not done" and close the dog without finishing...they just run into lunch/stay late that day.
# Posted By Alli | 5/16/08 3:55 PM
Emily, re:

"best speed of operating for the animal is an optimum not a minimum . . . "

You said it better than I could have. Thanks. The issue with those surgeries is the idea of making speed a competition -- anyway, rather than elaborate, I will reiterate that you said it all.
# Posted By Stefani | 5/16/08 5:48 PM
One needs to trust that the vets who earn your presence on the doorstep of their clinic have the good judgement and good sense to know what's appropriate for each situation. That or vote with your feet. IOW, I'm not offended in the least and give a thumbs up to Dr. K. for another interesting post. I like these peeks inside vet medicine.
# Posted By Deanna | 5/16/08 6:40 PM
Re: Pearl's spinal surgery (case in virtual hospital). Between the MRI & surgery, she was "out" for a very long time, as long as my 'significant other' was out for his spinal surgery. I was very concerned of detrimental effects of long anesthesia, but am happy to say there has never been any change (of personality, mental dullness, etc. ) . I can't bring myself to say the same for my 'other', though. (perhaps long-term effects of pain medication, too)

I say swiftness appropriate to skill AND surgical procedure!
# Posted By Barbara A. Albright/New Hampshire | 5/16/08 6:59 PM
VIRTUAL VET HOSPITAL
Got a sick pet? Visit our Virtual Vet Hospital and admit your own pets as patients in Dolittler's unique pet healthcare forum.
PODCASTS
New! Download our latest podcasts:
ARCHIVES
FAVORITE POSTS
RECOMMENDED
CAREERISTS
Did you always want to be a vet or vet technician? Thinking about it? Working on it? Need some Help?
VetInfo.com
AVMA
Miami Vet Specialist
Penn Vet School
DVM.com
VIN
Vet News Network
Vet Practice News
Vetstoria
"The greatness of a nation can be judged by the way its animals are treated."
- Mohandas Gandhi
This blog is running version 5.003.