Here’s a light topic to follow a tough week’s woe-is-me stress-fest: Shoes in veterinary practice.
I confess: I love shoes. No, not in the Sex in the City kind of way where shoes are an antidote to lovelessness and the sedative of choice for our collectively obnoxious, whining femininity. (Can you tell I’m not a fan?)
But I still love shoes in a way that I’ll agree has its feminine side (if only because glam rock fashion never made it big with the men). And that’s partly why I won’t wear ugly clogs and massive Crocs to work when surgery days can easily accommodate a great pair of running shoes or a spongy set of platforms.
To me, being a veterinarian does not denote ugly footwear. In fact, it ensures I have all the freedom I need to be myself. Animals don’t care what’s on your feet, right? (Unless it smells yummy.)
That’s why I read an article in this month’s Veterinary Practice News (VPN) with a gleam in my eye, knowing their treatment of just-right veterinary footwear would force my hand and occasion a post just like this one. (Sorry, couldn't find a link to the article.)
If you happened to read my VPN article (reprised in a past post) in which I defended every vet’s right to don whatever clothes he or she felt comfortable wearing, you’ll already know how I really feel. But if you noticed the letters to the editor that followed you’ll also know that my choice of footwear was roundly disparaged.
I don’t expect the average vet in Middle America to understand my penchant for five-inch platforms but I guess I do kind of expect some basic tolerance. I mean, at least I’m open-minded when it comes to their zeal for clogs, loafers and other ergonomically designed footwear.
This was my detractors’ take: Dr. Khuly can wear what she wants but she doesn’t do a service to the veterinary profession in so doing. And her shoes are horribly unsafe! We couldn’t let her work at our hospital because her shoes defy OSHA regulations.
Though the jury may be out on my service to my profession, it’s that last statement I can’t quite wrap my head around. After all, medical footwear the kind the VPN article and most persnickety vets address in idealized terms probably isn't OSHA compliant either.
That's because shoes must supposedly cover the entire foot, including the heel, for maximum security. Most all clogs are therefore disallowed. The uber-popular Crocs are even worse as they have syringe-unfriendly holes through which an ill-handled needle may well strike your flesh.
(Much-touted though clogs may be, some of us can’t wear ‘em anyway—they give our arches a nasty kind of stretch and we slip on everything when we’re in them. Don’t ask me why heels don’t offer me the same discomfort and insecurity—perhaps it’s the recommendable emotional je ne cest qoi they offer.)
I've often thought that if OSHA had its way, almost every clog and doc shoe in the uniform stores would be banned. It’s back to the white, rubber-soled, no-rise, lace-up nurse’s shoe of the past. That, or the simple sneaks I think make the best sense if we’re talking simple safety.
But we aren’t just talking safety, right? Shoes are the kind of intangible asset every single person feels kind of picky about. Whether it’s the pair of $700 Manolos used for stalking the urban bachelor (á la Sex in the City) or the open-toed Nike-soled Cole Haans (below) I consider my worthiest work shoes, footwear is clearly a touchy subject.
I'm comfortable in my shoes. I feel safe. I've never had a foot injury in thirteen years. I've never had a "slip and fall" accident. Apart from risking extra stress should a can of dog food land on my foot I don't see what the fuss is about.
So show me this OSHA rule if you want to fire me (I can't find it in our OSHA kit). Or don't hire me if you don't like someone with personality in her footwear. Here's a sampling (though these aren't my typical work shoes):
Ultimately, I think all those self-styled OSHA police should just shut up and ‘fess up to their true crime: intolerance (and maybe a pair of supposedly OSHA non-compliant Crocs in the OR, too).
P.S.But wait...I think I finally found a pair of Crocs I can actually wear. Four inches of heel for fifty bucks. Whaddaya think? Silver...or red?
Add Comment19 Comments
Guess what I found...OSHA says...
"OSHA does not have a specific policy, or guidelines, on the wearing of open-heeled shoes. However, OSHA does have regulations pertaining to personal protective equipment, and more specifically, to protective footwear. They are found at 29 CFR 1910.132 and 1910.136 (copies enclosed). 29 CFR 1910.136(a) requires the use of protective footwear when employees are working in areas where there is a danger of foot injuries due to falling or rolling objects, or objects piercing the sole, and where there is a possibility of the employee's feet being exposed to an electrical hazard.
In general, the standards require that foot protection be used whenever it is necessary by reason of hazard of processes or environment which could cause foot injury. If you are exposed, however infrequently, to those hazards during the course of your business activities, then, during that period of exposure, you would be required to wear protective footwear. If an employee is not exposed to any hazards to the feet, then the use of protective footwear would not be required.
Normally, the employer will determine which, if any, of the employees are exposed to a foot injury hazard. Ultimately, the determination of appropriate footwear in the absence of any of the previously mentioned hazards would be a matter for labor-management negotiation to which OSHA would not be a party."
For the full text: http://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_docum...
Dr. Patty Khuly May 31st, 2008 11:13:00 PM
Silver...I think red looks too flashy which equals too trashy. I don't see footwear being a problem for vets or anyone else. You could wear ballerina slippers, tight pants, and a bikini top and while I may find it "odd", as long as you know what you're doing and talk to me as if I've got half a brain -- then I don't give a damn.
I'm sure the ones that regulates my boyfriend's family business (where I work), if they actually walked on in my shift, then they would have a hell of a time discussing my dress issues..
ashleigh June 1st, 2008 12:40:00 AM
RED...totally....
there is NOTHING like a great pair of red shoes.
LorriM June 1st, 2008 12:50:00 AM
I am a gi doc who does proceedures every day, but I too love shoes. So I keep "sensible shoes" in the OR and change. ( I've been barfed on, pooped on and discovered that NOTHING stains like bile! And shoe covers don't work well.) But back in the office in the afternoon I change back to cute shoes for office hours. I stash 4 pairs under my desk and change to one that suites my outfit. And being south Florida, these are heels with open toes showing off my new pedicure. Phooey on crocs! They are too ugly.
Also, I vote for red.
kate7047 June 1st, 2008 09:52:00 AM
Ugly though they may be, I wouldn't trade my Crocs for the world. They are the only shoes I've found that keep my feet comfortable for an entire day of running around like an idiot. I do have the ones without holes on the top. I'm not so worried about falling needles, but rather falling bodily fluids.
katie June 1st, 2008 10:55:00 AM
One of my colleagues teaches microbiology in heels and a business skirt. I don't feel it's appropriate attire for her to wear for her own safety, or for modeling for the students (mostly nursing majors), but I also believe it's her right to choose what she wants. Our college president tried to get us to adopt a clothing policy that would've banned T-shirts and jeans, and it was laughed out of the room. One of my colleagues teaches energy utilities, and she requires her students to wear T-shirts and jeans (not to mention steel toed boots and hardhats).
In my shoes, I go for comfort over looks, and professionalism when I do consider looks, not flashiness. In my clothing I start the semester going for a professional look (to make a good impression on the students), and by the end of the semester I've degenerated to comfort.
zandperl June 1st, 2008 11:12:00 AM
You need help. :) My wife is Latina and has the same affection for collection.
Alex June 1st, 2008 12:16:00 PM
Silver. And where did you find those? I want my own pair.
Deanna June 2nd, 2008 08:57:00 AM
Love the green ones in the last photo - are they from this season, and if so- where might I find them? Lovely!
I would personally snap an ankle walking around in those shoes all day - but I would wear the equivalent in ballerina flats for sure. If you are comfortable, you are happy. The world needs more happy vets!
Creature of Habit June 2nd, 2008 09:03:00 AM
I am so buying a pair of those. You oughtta have affiliate links for some of this stuff you find, it would pay for the domain at least :)
emily June 2nd, 2008 09:21:00 AM
Oh Yum!!!!!!!!!! I love them all. :)
Stephanie Masonbrink June 2nd, 2008 09:54:00 AM
ohhh....you have excellent taste in shoes!!!!
homeless parrot June 2nd, 2008 10:36:00 AM
The canvas ones with green piping are Marc Jacobs from about 5 seasons ago. Got those on eBay about 3-4 years ago. Am I the only one here who buys shoes and glasses on eBay?
Dr. Patty Khuly June 2nd, 2008 11:13:00 AM
Here's an eBay outlet for the Crocs with heels:
http://cgi.ebay.com/Crocs-Cyprus-High-heel-Sandal-...
Dr. Patty Khuly June 2nd, 2008 12:40:00 PM
I just bid on hte green-brown and pink ones :) Hoping to get a bargain at $40.
emily June 2nd, 2008 03:44:00 PM
emily: The multicolored ones are three-inch heels. Hope that's OK with you. ;-)
Dr. Patty Khuly June 2nd, 2008 06:57:00 PM
oh boy, I just don't fit in on this post...I have been threatened by the fashion police at work for years: tiny puppy-teeth holes in my socks and not the right color, sneakers that look too much like bowling shoes, too much mileage gotten out of my Wal-mart clothes...
Most were convinced that I was totally frugal. Haven't been reprimanded for quite sometime, I kinda miss it.
Barbara A. Albright/New Hampshire June 2nd, 2008 07:54:00 PM
Dr. Khuly,
Just wanted to say thank you for reading my VPN article and giving it a shout out. For the record, I think it's great you have a fondness for platforms and like to express yourself. I have long preferred steel-toed Doc Martins to typical office shoes so we see eye-to-eye (or should I say shoe-to-shoe?) on this one.
Keep up the great work!
Elisa
Elisa June 3rd, 2008 05:12:00 PM
Elisa: I still keep about six pairs of variously colored Doc Martins in my closet in a box next to my Breyer's horses. I canot bring myself to eBay or otherwise rid myself of either.
Dr. Patty Khuly June 5th, 2008 08:49:00 AM
Add Commment